Set up? I could have set up 1 of those tries. I don't have a massive problem resigning him, he has had 1 bad season, the problem is that he has been given FOUR YEARS. A repeat of this year next season and it would be time to get rid, no matter how sympathetic we are to one of the few blokes from the South who has risen to a decent level. But we would not be able to. We are a professional Rugby League club, we cannot be loyal to those from the south for the sake of it as they will be disloyal to us (LMS).

Hopefully.

Did you see the highlights of the Reds game last night before the Leeds/Saints game.

Clubby came flying out of the line and missed his man resulting in a score-If I was the opposition coach I would expose this every time-decent sides always put runners through the back so why not tempt Clubby into a dummy runner opening a wide hole-To make it worse when he runs out of the line he goes inwards on an angle and makes the hole even bigger-You could possibly deal with it if he went straight up because that would force the ball carrier out wide whereas running in opens the whole up in front of the ball carrier.

Why doesnt Mac say if you come out of the line again I'm going to drop you-simple. I wouldnt expect an amateur side to make the same mistake repeatedly never mind SL standard. If you stay in the line the decision sits with the attacking team., if you open a hole up there is no decision

I'm not sure I've ever seen a player go south as dramatically as Clubb has over the last two years. To think he was knocking on the doorr of the World Cup squad in 2008 and then to look at him now, you couldn't believe it was the same player. I'd like to know what the reason for this is, we're not just talking about a simple loss of form. Maybe Quins feel that a 4-year contract is a big statement of belief in his ability. It's possible that that is what he needs to restore his confidence. Bottom line for me is that he is not as bad a player as he has been for (most) of this season, so something needs to be done to help him get back on track.

It's clearly Brian McDermott's fault, everything else is.