I'd assume they'd say "with this signing our squad is complete"

Well they have announced on twitter their squad is complete and you can now vote for squad numbers and do heir fantasy team. We will have to see.

We don`t need Hardaker, he is a loose cannon and causes trouble.
We are apparently going with what we have, and that will do me as we have some good players, just need motivating and good conditioning. These clubs signing 5 and 6 players always have trouble getting them to gel.

Who says we are going with what we have. Stone says he needs a full back an outside back and a forward. Currently we don't have anyone to play full back next year. Someone will be brought in.

I know which game (Still got it on DVD) what I was asking was which punch?

Just inside info. Unless it is being held close to the chest for secrecy.
But with what we have Murphy could go to full-back, and Ormsby to wing, he has the ability just needs him to knuckle down and get on with the job, he is a strong finisher.

That sounds perfect if we want to play championship in 2018

At the last HGSA meeting the question re FB were quite clear.

So we not going without the Bradford 3?

We may not need Hardaker but we certainly need someone, If you think we can go with the same squad and get different results , well good luck with that. There is only so much changing players round you can do, eg. Ellis backup Hooker perhaps ?

The idea is to keep trying to strengthen the first choice team, not just plod on with the same or get more mediocrity in from Bradford. The club needs to get away from that attitude, It's held sway for far too long at the Giants.

What stone thinks/ or would like to do may be irrelevant if we have no wiggle room on the cap. If we can't offload unwanted players(and why would anyone want players unwanted by the bottom team) then he may have no choice.

According to most, Anderson was the problem last year, not the players, now people are saying we need to completely overhaul the squad more or less, but it's not knee jerking?
So basically, last season,either the coaching, conditioning,players, chairman, MD, kit man, etc were to blame for our poor showing

I think the current squad can do much better with better coaching and being fitter which is what most were saying last season. I agree with your point about the Bradford 3 but in general up to the last 6 months most of the signings have improved the squad. I would bracket Ormsby in with these 3, I don't consider him any better than what we have. We brought 3 good players in part way through last season don't forget and I expect some more progress from the younger players, Roberts in particular. I expect a much better season for us, how good remains to be seen, but I don't think this year's top 4 are spectacularly better than the rest so a good coach, a return to proper fitness and the right attitude could see a return to the higher reaches. Think positive!!

Bringing a good full back in will be the difference between us making top 4 and finishing in the bottom 4 in my eyes.

I agree with most of that, and i have said all along It's as much about coaching as anything else, But there are positions where we need new players and fullback is one of them, IMO we need to replace Big Eorl if possible (just an opinion ) If money is as tight as some people think ( and I'm not saying they are wrong ) Then let the likes of Murphy and Ormsby fight it out for a spot on the wing, But we do need at least a couple of new players, If for eg Wardle goes we need a good replacement.

And most people were right about Anderson. I would hardly call saying we need a couple of players, calling for a complete overhaul of the squad either, or a knee jerk.

Why don't you tell us why you think we finished bottom of the pile and had such a sh*te season.

The team needs boosting,
Hardaker, is an undoubted talent, carn,t think of a better one that is available
We need a FB
He has been a kno2head, he would not be alone at the Giants.
He is older, hopefully wiser
Step forward the person on hear who has,nt been there.

On the Rhinos board, Cas had it all done and dusted, 90K, till the Giants stepped in, make of that what you will.

Ive heard something similar but you don't know what to believe.

Ive heard we offered 120k + Kyle Wood for Hardaker, whether Hardaker wants to come to us is a different matter.

The only thing in our favour is if he wants to play in the England squad in the world cup he is going to have to be on form no mater who he plays for.

Well let's hope cas win out. We Arent in a position where we can afford to take on a player with known "issues" who would rather be going elsewhere. If he wants to go to cas it's not in our best interest to try and force otherwise.

Yorkshire Evening Post has printed in a article tonight that Hardaker will be announced as a Huddersfield player after Cas didn't match our offer. Interesting times.......

Agree with that really, I'm not put off by his reputation, there are plenty as bad, He is a class act but i wouldn't get into a bidding war over him. There will be quality fullbacks in the lower level in Oz, they just need finding.

Mamo has fractured his ankle on Holiday and will be out till Feb. Deal possibly may still get done ..... www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-8194947 Hardaker bit is at the bottom of the artice https://twitter.com/NothingButNK/status ... 6885850112 Mamo article, which also still say Hardaker off to Cas explains why it has not been announced yet. Will we sign him anyway? Will still be ready to play at the start of the year but will miss alot of pre season bur should not be too hard to get a winger fit and we have a good reputation getting players back fit from injury. Will we wait till he has recovered? If Wardle was part of a deal will he miss Newcastle pre season? So we may see a Mid season swap. Interesting couple of months to come from the Giants....

Mamo has fractured his ankle on Holiday and will be out till Feb. Deal possibly may still get done ..... www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-8194947 Hardaker bit is at the bottom of the artice https://twitter.com/NothingButNK/status ... 6885850112 Mamo article, which also still say Hardaker off to Cas explains why it has not been announced yet. Will we sign him anyway? Will still be ready to play at the start of the year but will miss alot of pre season bur should not be too hard to get a winger fit and we have a good reputation getting players back fit from injury. Will we wait till he has recovered? If Wardle was part of a deal will he miss Newcastle pre season? So we may see a Mid season swap. Interesting couple of months to come from the Giants....

Quote ="GiantJake1988"Mamo has fractured his ankle on Holiday and will be out till Feb. Deal possibly may still get done ..... www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-8194947 Hardaker bit is at the bottom of the artice https://twitter.com/NothingButNK/status ... 6885850112 Mamo article, which also still say Hardaker off to Cas explains why it has not been announced yet. Will we sign him anyway? Will still be ready to play at the start of the year but will miss alot of pre season bur should not be too hard to get a winger fit and we have a good reputation getting players back fit from injury. Will we wait till he has recovered? If Wardle was part of a deal will he miss Newcastle pre season? So we may see a Mid season swap. Interesting couple of months to come from the Giants....'" So one paper says we've signed mamo, another says we have signed hardaker. Sounds to me like we've signed no one and this is all speculation!

Quote ="GiantJake1988"Mamo has fractured his ankle on Holiday and will be out till Feb. Deal possibly may still get done ..... www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/s ... -1-8194947 Hardaker bit is at the bottom of the artice https://twitter.com/NothingButNK/status ... 6885850112 Mamo article, which also still say Hardaker off to Cas explains why it has not been announced yet. Will we sign him anyway? Will still be ready to play at the start of the year but will miss alot of pre season bur should not be too hard to get a winger fit and we have a good reputation getting players back fit from injury. Will we wait till he has recovered? If Wardle was part of a deal will he miss Newcastle pre season? So we may see a Mid season swap. Interesting couple of months to come from the Giants....'" So one paper says we've signed mamo, another says we have signed hardaker. Sounds to me like we've signed no one and this is all speculation!

From what I hear Hardaker to play FB, Mamo Wing. (COULD BE BOLLOCKS) buts lets Just say this happened and Wardle went to Newcastle, Eorl retired and Wood went to Leeds.

1. Hardaker
2. McGilvarry
3. Cudjoe
4. Murphy
5. Mamo
6. Brough
7. Brierley
8. Rapira
9. Ellis/Leeming
10. Huby
11. Symonds
12. Taai
13. Hinchliffe

14. Roberts 2nd ROW
15. Leeming/Ellis
16. Lawrence 2nd ROW
17. Smith PROP
18. Mason PROP
19. Ikahihifo 2nd ROW
20. Ormsby WING

Youngsters
S. Wood CENTRE
Jacob Wardle CENTRE
Tyler Dickinson PROP
Darnell Mcintosh WING
Liam Johnson 2nd ROW

Mikey Wood - Probably be released
Jared Simpson - Probably be released

From this its easy to see why the Bradford 3 maybe signed as squad players as we will be very short even still, especially in the PROPS.

You have Gaskell as a poor mans Rat boy Ratchford and can cover every position 1, 3/4, 6 & 7 and would probably end up in the centres instead of Murphy with Murph on the wing till Mamo is fit then Murph goes to Centre cover.

Fergy 2nd Row cover
Clough Prop cover