Roby plays in a different position!

Tickle is nowhere near the class of JT.

Ferris? Who's that?

Please go elsewhere to advertise your rugby ignorance.

To use your phrase, we can agree to disagree.

Now run along and get your favourite photo of Joel Tompkins, your rose tinted specs and a box of kleenex

Irony. Ha.

Still can't find a Ferris. Unless you mean Ferriol, the French prop. As that's the closest I can find.

Feel free to prove me wrong though, it wouldn't be the first time!

Rugby ignorance and yet you don't know how to spell a players name.

Don't turn this into a spelling forum sweetheart. Your wet dreams about lil Joel are duly noted. Perhaps you can find another forum were your fixation is shared?

I would have Westwood, Tickle, Ferres or Mossop ahead of JT. However i am looking at this re rugby...I suspect you are not

How would you have Mossop over JT? He's not even played a full season yet and definately wouldn't get in the side ahead of JT.

The others (bar Westwood) are nowhere near as good.

And thankfully I have never had a wet dream about Joel, not my type! haha.

Pity he plays in a different position though, out of interest why your a master of knowledge on stats how does Tickles Ferris's and Westwoods compare? Il have a guess and say not as well.

I heard of this but could not believe it.....

You soon changed your spots.

Ha ha ha...

Ridiculous replies tbh.

I think it should definately be applauded you've got so many players in the England setup, I was just trying to discuss how many would actually get in the side. The only ones i've really "bagged" was Crabtree as I don't think he's had a particularly good season, and Griffin just because I think Fieldens better.

Where is Cudjoe's best position btw? He's one i'm glad is in the squad as he has the talent and size to make one of the backs positions his own (just not quite yet I think)

Careful Bill. Inside man is a stickler re spelling and grammar. He will ridicule your poor use of apostrophes and incorrect spelling of 'your'. And you say 'he plays' when I refer to several players. Who on earth is 'he'?

Using stats is always questionable. I do know the stats on penalties if that is any help to you.

HTH

Heard it where?

And you could not believe that someone rates these players ahead of the sainted Joel? I could understand that you disagree with it. But that you do not have the capacity to believe such a thing is deeply touching. I will pray for you.

Do you mean the replies where you resorted to criticising a poster's spelling? I agree it was petty and ridiculous.

You may think it silly of me to question your opinion, as you get to watch many of our ex players week in, week out. But please remember that you only watch our rejects. Hence my belief that i consider your reasoning flawed.

The spelling of a players name, in the same post as trying to criticise my rugby knowledge. I found it ironic that's all.

And now you peddle the lame 'Wigan rejects' drivel that was popular with the the intellectually challenged a couple of years ago. Is that the best you have got?

The intelligences required for spelling and understanding rugby are not one and the same. People have different intelligences. So there would be irony if I mispelled a name while criticising your spelling. Not the case, so your reply was indeed ridiculous.

HTH.

Was Griffin a Wiganer? Was Crabtree? Was Cudjoe? Was Lunt?

Please tell me this is a joke? That may be the most biased post i have ever seen. You basically want any huddersfield player in the 17? Regardless that there are clearly better options?

Inside man is such a dreary wimp that he opened a thread on my comments on the Wigan forum! Obviously desperate for other members of the Joel Tomkins wet dream society to reassure him. He has taken being a softc**k to a new level.

Sounds wimpish. He didn't have an argument to come back with so went to ask his friends to make one up for him. ROFL.

I knew that as soon as I read his first line, the thread was destined to end in bother.

Go on then...outline these "better" options to me...

Play all of Wigans options first and then consider other players.

If they play for wigan they must be the best. End of.