Nope not a sack him thread, sorry to disappoint, but more his post match comments



i know people will straight away say that it's his job to get the players motivated etc etc, but i see it as the opposite here, if the players aren't doing their jobs and the coach is as frustrated as the fans are, then should we drop some players, obviously Baloo isn't gonna name names and we still have players out, but for me, if a player isn't doing a job for the team he should be out of the team, simple as.

I agree if players are not doing their jobs they lose their place....Obviously diificult at the moment with the injuries but that threat needs to be carried through when enough are available to have any credibility. If we are to have any chance of being half decent we need all players giving their all to the same plan.

It is an empty threat because we dont have a squad big enough to be dropping players.

We went into this season with a squad that was too small. Backed up by a lot of youngsters who are not ready.We then lost two players and are paying the price when players get injured.

TBH I though Anderson made a poor choice having Mason and larne on the bench as our two "props" against the biggest side in SL. JJ should have played. Drop Connor and Wardle for me. Both are making poor decisions and giving away penalties. Sam wood in for Connor and JJ back move larne to second row.

He said as much himself on the Yorkshire radio interview after the game

Just hope we have wardle eorl and huby for next week

Like all (good) managers Anderson blames his Players.
Nothing to do with him ? Typical from him who grunts and moans every week. Never blames himself for tactics or team selection. Could he be losing the changing room?????? rumours.

Both the captain and the coach said that the players' attitude and application was wrong yesterday.

so let's blame the coach eh!

there will always be rumours around, but these rumours only get dragged out when the team loses, there was no mention of sacking the coach or rumours last week strangely enough.

Anderson's job now is to life those players and shake that CBA attitude out of them unless wakey will beat us, if we have a good easter with 3/3 then no one will be bothered again, like last week.

Which Captain would that be then?? Is Danny happy?? did not look like he was. watch out.

Ryan Hinchliffe is the captain.

Craig told me himself that he'll be back for the Wakey game on Friday.

The captain and coach may well be right , but not just about yesterday, There are far too many performances like that through a season.

You are right about it being Andersons job to lift the side up, which I think is not his best quality, As you well know I am not a fan of his, I don't think he can motivate them, nor can he threaten them either, they know the situation better than we do, The performances , Good or bad, seem to depend on what mood takes their fancy.

I didn't expect to beat Catalan with the side we can put out at the moment, but even with a full pack to choose from we have a relatively slow and lethargic pack with a distinct lack of fight for most games, Why can we put up so much fight in some games such as Wigan and Leeds and yet get rolled over with such ease like yesterday.
It happens at most clubs from time to time, but at most clubs do something about it, If we lose to Wakey ( God forbid ) It may well be squeaky bottom time for Mr Anderson. The only things he has to use, is of course the injury list, but to be honest, I don't think Smith is any better that Kopczak (if as good ) and Huby is not the offloading forward he was at Cas. so don't see those two would have transformed us, Mullally had more go forward than both and he hardly got on the field .
I don't say Mr Anderson is responsible for the hiring and firing of course, but he is certainly the one to be held responsible for their attitude on the field, If he can't stop them repeatedly giving away endless Penalties who are we to look to. Anyway whoever does the Hiring and firing he is the one who will lose his job when the crunch comes.

Attitude and application, from the players. as has been alluded to.

I don't think Baloo is, or will look for excuses, why would he?

as for hiring and firing, then you are having a laugh if you think they will be sacked.

Should have sacked em all last week for having the audacity to win and making lots of people have to delete or delay ready written posts for this forum and the facebook ones !!!!

if we lost 2 of r next 3 games hes gotta go hes taking us no where at all poor in attack n shocking in defence yesterday no effort or motivation at all from the players n surly its andersons job to motivate the players

what if we win 2 out of the next 3, is he good enough then?

no ive never really been a fan of anderson so ill b glad t see him go if he does

Fair enough ,as long as you're not being fickle



so genuine question, who would replace him?

no im not fickle pal i liked nathan browns style of rugby we seemed t much more fast flowing rugby with brown in charge n tbh i dunno who i raplace him with maybe a unknown ozzy like nathan brown

First saying we should sign hock. Now saying brown was good


I call troll

so you're advocating sacking a coach who has improved us from the previous coach, and replace him with a coach like the previous coach


to be fair we did play some good stuff under NB but we also didn't have much in the way of structures etc, despite what people think of our style of "football" etc, we have a very good record under PA.

i dont no how u can say PA is a better coach than brown when brown got us t the cc final what has PA done for us nothing hes not really signed any good players all r good signing come from brown n the last 3 season weve been finishing lower in the league each season so how can u say PA is any better than brown

Because we have been consistent under Anderson, we haven't failed to finish outside the top 4 in his tenure, yes we haven't made a final under him, but we are the best team in the league under Anderson in terms of games played and won, no mean feat.He is also the only coach in 81 years to lead us to a league winners title!

I have nowt against Brown, and rate him highly, he did a fantastic job for us but it just ended badly, but like Anderson, he couldn't get us over the line in terms of trophies, and yes he got us to a cup final, but so did Jon Sharp.

I meant Mr Anderson is the one who will lose his job Meast.