Title says it all.

Just wanted to even up the sin bins didn't he

becoming an utter liability now ive completely had it with the bloke.

That said every single Cas fan shouting "cheat" to Thaler should be absolutely ashamed - that bloke won you that game tonight.

Can't say he cost us it, we had ample opportunities to score more before he went. I counted at least one occasion arriving at their try line on tackle 2 and still not even getting over. We must spend more time in the final 5m without scoring than any other team. We really need to play the ball quick for a full 80 rather than just patches, play for the penalties or you gain massive yards, stop running into markers and wasting tackles. Just dumb rugby time and again.

Lot better performance overall, big individual performances but with the players they had out, Cas really were there for the taking tonight.

Third home game sin binned and people still applaud as he comes off,will get a ban for that and rightly so,needs a stronger coach than Stone to reign him in.Some very difficult decisions need to be taken and soon

No he didn't. The penalty and sin binning of Webster was joke. he strips the ball one on one when the tackle clearly isn't completed.
Not sure on the Minikin penalty for tackle in the air. Mamo fails to collect the ball and its gone forward before Minikin makes contact.

Whereas the one on Darnell.....
A more "experienced" player like say Monaghan would have hit the deck like a sack of spuds and stayed down to get the call. Because Darnell was so keen to get up Thaler didn't even give him a talking to. That looked like it was dangerous play and should have been dealt with as such.

High intensity game and things happen in the heat of the moment. Broughy was our best player along with Mamo. But at the same time our winger was taken out in the air (dangerous tackle) we got the panalty, but nothing was said. ???

Good player is Brough but he lost you that game today.
Unfortunately I can't see anything other than relegation for you this year
Very poor side and the Championship looms
We were there for the taking with big players missing

If he wasn't playing we wouldn't have come close to beating Castleford tonight. He's the best leader and creative player we've got and I'd go as far as to say he's been our best signing since we've been in super league and when he does hang up his boots (hopefully he's still with us) then we should put him on the coaching staff and groom him for the top job. Class player who has it all still.

If he wasn't playing we wouldn't have come close to beating Castleford tonight. He's the best leader and creative player we've got and I'd go as far as to say he's been our best signing since we've been in super league and when he does hang up his boots (hopefully he's still with us) then we should put him on the coaching staff and groom him for the top job. Class player who has it all still.

Is he a player playing like someone who is trying to force a move without looking like a bad players.

Bad player no one wants.

Good player who makes a costly mistake every game becomes a liability so the club sack him off ?

im team broughwas very harsh and ref was evening the sin bins up

Was it hell harsh. It was undefendable. Cheap shot that could have caused manor injury. Hence Millington's fury and he's normally the calmest player on the field. He's been since binned 3 times in your last 3 home games, if you think that is acceptable you are as deluded as he is a brat.

Woke up this morning.

Brekkie - check
Cup of tea - check
Read newspaper - check
Felt ashamed for calling Thaler "cheat" last night ? - nope. I feel mighty fine.

It wasn't harsh at all. It was a clear yellow card.

And for what? A brain fart.

We would not have been close to the Castleford score last night if it hadn't have been for Danny Brough's creativity! It was great to see Murphy pass out to Mamo to score but everything else comes from Broughy's brain. It was obvious why we lost the game - Smith drops the ball, TRY to Cas. Wakeman drops the ball, TRY to Cas. Simple mistakes cost us the game again. Let's hope they continue to play with the same spirit and the wins will follow.

yeh two very costly errors there indeed

cut out those and we would be winning! but hard to have a perfect performance

getting there now though...taken a while! need to keep on this track now

As a neutral, the Webster sin bin was incorrect. Fair one on one ball strip. Brough was reckless at best, yellow card and possible ban was correct. Hudds had enough chances to win the game earlier and bombed them. Loss was not the refs faults but Hudds inability to capitalise on opportunities. See you in the mid 8s.

Add insult to injury, our average gate in the championship with nearly zero away support is about 1.5k more than you had last night.

Brough is looking like a player that WANTS to get sacked. Hudds would be better off if they actually did, and freed up a large chunk of salary cap to boot.

As in no is anywhere close to what bd does

Cheers Broughy lad thanks for the great memories,think you might be a hard act to follow.

He wants to get sacked?! And a sin binning for a dangerous tackle is the way to achieve this in his mind, it is planned that way?! Brilliant theory. Get a grip.

Ps thanks for the crowd info, and your advice on how our club should proceed. Enjoy your trip to Batley with your big impressive following.

Got to laugh,when right edge d let's in tries.

Leroy hoping you will be back soonest .

you worry about salfords crowds not ours.

if people think getting rid of brough is the answer then you are wrong

Not sure what people have been watching but how many good games has Brough had this year? Leeds he was class but before that can't really say he has been playing as the highest earner on the team should, he bollox the youngsters and not in a encouraging way but then makes a cock up himself and seems like he is untouchable, he is 34 now and in the past has been a great player but he is struggling now and spends more time in stand than playing. With a sensible head on and been honest to ourselves its time to get shut, free up some cap space along with the Brierley money and build a team around team players not 1 individual that wants to do it all, facts are Ellis was great at Cas, came to Giants and couldnt have same impact alongside Brough but running things at Hull KR, same with Brierley was stifled at Giants, if someone offered to swap Brough with George Williams I would snap their hand off!!!! Prob 5-6 of the experienced lads I would keep and rest haven't done enough