For me it's

1.Grix
20.McGilvary
3.Cudjoe
4.Gilmour
5.Hodgson
6.Brown
7.Brough
15.Mason
14.Lunt
10.Griffin
11.O'Donnell(may be dropped for poor performance) Possibly Kirmond if Nathan brown disappointed with O'Donnelll
12.Fa'alogo
13.Faiumu

37.Ferguson
8.Crabtree
18.Patrick
36.Simpson

grix
mcgilvary
cudjoe
simpson
hodgson
brown
brough
mason
lunt
griffin
faalogo
gilmour
o'donnell


crabtree
patrick
faimu
ferguson

1.Grix
20.McGillvary
3.Cudjoe
4.Gilmour
5.Hodgson
6.Brown
7.Brough
15.Mason
14.Lunt
10.Griffin
11.O'Donnell
12.Fa'alogo
13. Faiumu

8.Crabtree
36.Simpson
37.Ferguson
18.Patrick

Well the 2 new guys won't be playing for a month at least. In fact the squad has been told after the wolves game that the team wont be changed for month... Lets see if that performance forces his hand.

Unless there are injuries

grix
mcgilvary
cudjoe
Lawrence
Hodgson
brown
brough
mason
lunt
Eorl
faalogo
gilmour
o'donnell


Raleigh
patrick
fuey
Griffin

Big lads in for the big Hull pack

well obviously, heard Keal's not too well.

I think Lawrence is a doubt as well so that would put Simpson in the frame. I was just making the point that despite assurances by Brown about giving the players a month and having a settled team he would make changes if he was unhappy with someone.

How longs robbo out for

Really think we need him at hooker.

We've got Lunt or Fooey to play hooker so i dont think we have a problem there but i do think we are missing Robbo's organisation.

I'd go with that.

What happened to Carlile?

Also Eorl had an ice pack on his arm at the end.

Also his little scampering runs

How long till he's back from injury

Really like robbo and think he's a super player

i think larne patrick will be very very unlucky if he misses out again!

GRIX
CUDJOE
GILMOUR
LAWRENCE
MCGILVARY
BROWN
BROUGH
MASON
FAIUMU
PATRICK
FA'AOLOGO
O'DONNELL
KIRMOND

LUNT
CRABTREE
RALEIGH
HORNE

grix
mcgilvary
cudjoe
simpson
hodgson

brown
brough

mason
faiumu
griffin
faalogo
gilmour
o'donnell


crabtree
patrick
Lunt
Raleigh

Grix
McGilvary
Cudjoe
Gilmour
Hodgson

Brown
Brough

Mason
Lunt
Griffin
O'donnell
Fa'alogo
Patrick

Faiumu
Crabtree
Raleigh
Kirmond

Don't think Simpson or Ferguson will be upto speed or fitness yet, Carlile & Bruno missing through injury.

With the way NB uses his 13 I think the position will suit Patrick - plenty of carries up the middle. Our 13 tends to be more of a third prop than anything else.

How long Robbo out for

With NB coaching he may adapt to loose very quickly,very strong and fast.Sure hope he gets named in team this week.

About another 4 weeks, missing him at the moment. Robbo and Lunt interchanging at 9 will be pretty immense with the form Lunt is carrying at the moment.

Grix

McGilvary
Simpson
Cudjoe
Hodgson

Brown
Brough

Griffin
Faiumu
Mason
Fa'alongo
Patrick
O'Donnell

Crabtree
Lunt
Mason
Raleigh

You cannot have Mason playing twice

Stick with the same 19. You can't drop anybody after the Cas match cos about 12 or 13 players had poor matches and picking 1 or 2 out would be churlish.

If Carlisle and or Lawrence are out then bring in Patrick and Molloy (the two who missed out from the 19) I'd be tempted to give Lunt 80 at Hooker or rotate Grix and Brough at the PTB and pack down with a 2nd row/prop at hooker in the scrum. Gilmour to centre. Leave Faiumu on the bench and utilise him as a 2nd row, he's wasted at hooker where he can't use his best attributes ie his sidestep and offload.

Neither Simpson nor Ferguson should get in the side before the likes of Patrick, Molloy, Wardle, Raleigh, Kirmond etc cos they haven't earned it yet.

I agree that players should not be dropped for that one game, however I would be tempted to rotate one or two and prehaps bring in a couple of fresh forwards to deal with Hull's pack - especially after we were beaten by Castleford's on Saturday.

Moving Gilmour to the centres, bringing in Patrick, Raleigh and Kirmond with Bruno and Carlile out injured allows us to put a stronger pack up against Hull.