meh, to be honest I think your win at Headingley was much better and worthy of celebration.

For saying the side you beat a couple of days ago I reckon is at least 9 changes short of our best side, effectively 10 once you consider JJB left the field within 10 minutes.

Still, good win for you. Just hope we can meet you in the playoffs at full strength to inflict some revenge.

If Grix is moved from fullback it will be noticed immediately and not in a good way.

Murph is solid but he simply doesn't organise our defence as well, isn't as good a ball player

Grix is the best fullback we have, Broughton isn't an improvement over him either.

I agree, personally i wouldn't sign Broughton. We aren't short of wingers and he isn't better than either of our two starters. The cap money would be better spent elsewhere ie half back where we really need someone to help out Brough.

you are assuming we are keeping our two "starters".

Of course I'm assuming that but then again so is everyone else. Given the choice I'd keep Grix, Murphy, Mcgillevary as our back three. If one leaves then replace them but i wouldn't bring in Broughton to replace any of them if the option is to keep them. I'd be disapointed to see either Mcgillevary or Murphy go and I think we would struggle to replace Grix without paying money that would be better spent elsewhere in the team. The likes of Tomkins, Hodgson etc won't come cheap.

id like to see next season

murphy FB
mcgillvary wing
broughton wing

and bailey at loose



with ferres and chan..taai on the bench. and still have other options with lawrence etc