not clear who is the VR at catalans games??? is it anyone from the rfl even??

he looked at cudjoes try for ages trying his best to find something

on the other cudjoe try that didnt get given i do feel he was held up when i first saw it.

we do seem to be on the wrong end of the pens at games, its becoming an issue, so far this season think we have been on the right side of the pens awarded just twice???? is it all down to our ill discipline? do refs not like brough?!

I only saw the highlights on the super league show last night but it appears to me that:

1. Robbo was sent off on the basis of information provided by the touch judge.
2. the VR was only asked to look at the grounding for Leroy's try which was as plain as day on 1st viewing, so what the heck was the VR looking at for so long if this was the case?
3. the Taia try should have gone to the VR as looked like the ball was put down on a Giants player's hand.

the disallowed try wasn't shown so can't comment on that.

T Crashley was the video ref and Childs sent Robbo off on his advice that Robbo had made an illegal attack to the head

even catalans fans in perpignan were saying robbo didn't do anything and that it was accidental.
i think,similar to the o'donnell red card last year,the officials saw a player lying prone and panicked thinking something terrible had happened and that the player must walk.
shame they didn't think the same when casty launched his attack on robbo!

robbo was too honest, he should of laid down like escare did!