I think Finnegan should also start before the likes of Barlow.

you must be joking. NAME YOUR FORWARDS.

Karl Harrison

No matter who Halifax put on the park they will still be handicapped by their coach, as a lot of their own fans say.

A better way to judge maybe taking each player and asking would they get in the Leigh team. I think even the most staunch Leigh fan would admit that the forwards we use on match days, usually about 7 or 8, would all get in the Leigh team. On the other hand I think theres at least a couple of Leigh players named that wouldnt get in the fax team, players like Ostick, Duffy, and Aspinwall I think would struggle.

Yes just the lads from last season who were not on holiday.

Well Greg you might at least have put a wink after that post some might think you've been on the pop

.

I'd have to agree with Greg on at least one of those named.

Halifax may play as a team of individuals we play as a team, it is our coaches ethos.

Just a shame that other people at the club are not reading from the same script eh?

IMO I think we are & will be stronger than last season. Now some of the Fax fans finally realise that Riddy aint going any where how are you feeling with your new halve backs you currently have GFB?

Out of the whole entire fax team there are only a couple i would have at leigh and they are in the backline. Fieldhouse and Worrincy. I'd take Spencer over Davies, i'd take anybody from the under 16's at east or miners over Bracek, massively over rated. The front row at fax isn't that great or am i missing something? Ashall looks a good player to be fair, but don't know where we'd put him? Duffy is the only player who is a bit ropey in the pack, big season for that lad, gotta shift some weight and get more minutes.

On the whole I mostly agree with everything you state Rennie , though im to sure about your views on Bracek ,I think he is OK , and would be OK in most packs , although we have more than enough forwards now , im looking forward to signing a couple of Backs , and would love to see the Worrier , Worrincy in a Leigh shirt .

They are not playing staff members and TBH what goes on over here is of no interest to anyone else troll.

On the contrary I would say it makes for quite interesting reading.

I almost stopped reading when you said Ashall looks a fair player.

Maybe you are right though and players like Tonks, Ambler, Manning, and Murrell wouldnt get near the Leigh team.

I think without Murrell Fax would be average tbh.

Murrell? Are you having a laugh?! He can only pass in one direction, and even then it takes him five minutes to get his hands in the right place!

I think i tend to agree with you but every top team has a top stand out player so i would hope if we didnt have him then we would have another.

Before he broke his thumb he was leading the coaches picks for player of the year by some distance and it is really no surprise that his injury coincided with our worst form of the season. The guy is a pleasure to watch though.

I can only think you are on a wide up here otherwise you are just showing what a poor judge of a rugby league player you are.

Watch the game back from the LSV. That game just showed how much you rely on Thackeray. Camped on our line for long periods and he just didn't have the quality to put anyone over.

Spencer,Penky,Barlow,Wilkes,Goulden,Aspinwall bench Beswick, Bate,Ostick,Acton
will handle any "monsters" from Yorks

Oh right got ya. For a minute there I thought you were judging his season on one performance.

You realize Thackery didnt play at all the last few games of the season when we actually hit some of our best form of the year?

To know that, you must work for the RFL.

Best form? Not from what I could see!