On the other hand I imagine Mr Sherwin is reasonably happy not to have to sit on the sidelines for several weeks suffering from a fractured eye socket............or maybe its just me?

You mean like Stosic who played the next week without a fractured eye socket? So yes, it's just you.

Anyway, suppose we'll see. I like Moz and his biff, but that struck me as a bad one. Believe me, I want him to play against Wigan but I can't see how that can't be a ban - he followed through with a stiff arm.

Or 3. it was a deliberately malicious, head high attack on a player off the ball

That was also my opinion regarding Carvell although one of your fellow posters on here accused me of talking garbage.
I don't think there was much wrong with the Morley tackle, a little late, certainly a penalty, maybe a sin bin but not worthy of a ban.

Spot on mate. Can't speak for other Wire fans though.

Carvell is looking at 2-3 games and Moz 1-2 games, Called this afternoon to RFL

If that's true thats hampered our best start to the season in a decade.

With Wigan and then Huddersfield next up, that will be two losses and then we have Crusaders which should be a win. That would give us 6 out of a possible 10 points. Which i would suspect would be the same as Leeds point total after 5 games.

That is the bans that they get from the grading if found guilty

So you rang the RFL and they told you what bans the players were getting before the players themselves were told.

Read it properly moron, that is the grading they will get [uif found guilty[/u. Obviously dont know much about off field rugby do you

www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/superl ... p?id=16589

www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/superl ... p?id=16589

How about you read what you wrote. I replied to "Carvell is looking at 2-3 games and Moz 1-2 games, Called this afternoon to RFL" Where does it mention if charged or if found guilty.

Do players who have been cited ever get let off?

Both cited and up in front of panel tomorrow, just hope Solomona is fit for the weekend otherwise we are going to be a tad light up front.

Pack options should they both get banned

Wood
Monaghan
Cooper/Harrison
L Anderson
Westwood
Harrison/Grix/Solomona

It meant 'they were called today to the rfl'. Sure i would call the RFL and ask them

both will receive a minimum of 1 game each and possibly more in carvell case
both were needless incidents and could cost us dear

If these two are banned then so be it. It's a shame the opposition is Wigan, but being without the two first choice props will show us how good our back up is. Woody and Coop's won't let us down, our problem will be how to shuffle the second row to get two more props available. We need to find two props from Solomona, Westwood, L. Anderson, Harrison, Mitchell and McCarthy. If we do we will be weaker but not by much!

You'll be massively weakened if both are banned whoever you shuffle about. I don't mean that as a slant on the lads you can bring in or shift to prop but as a compliment to Carvell and Morley. They're 2 of the best 5 or 6 props in superleague and simply can't be replaced like for like from within the Wire squad.

Think both will probably get 2 game bans, both stupid and not required.

But have to ask will Fozzard should be cited every week coz he leads with his forearm into every tackle, just hit and miss as to where the contact is made on the tackler

www.therfl.co.uk/superleague/new ... p?id=16589

www.therfl.co.uk/superleague/new ... p?id=16589

What was Myler issued a warning for



? and how come the RFL aren't citing McGoldrick for swinging but yet they are citing Moz and Carvs. Typical.

It'll be on here tomorrow.
[urlhttp://www.therfl.co.uk/about/disciplinary.php[/url

Not sure whether it is or not but I seem to recall seeing him kick out at a player very early on. I think it was one of the first penalties for holding down by L Anderson.

McGoldrick has been cautioned.

I expect Carvell to get a ban but didn't think there was much in the Morley incident.

McGoldrick swung in Kings face yet is let off but Carvell running with the ball and makes accidental contact with an opposing player gets cited. The RFL are a joke.

Well as said earlier they have now both been cited by the RFL. Thank god mo lindsay isn't still chairman of the disciplinary commitee!