i dont know what to make of this??

is this good or bad??

How is Penny's development coming on was really exciting prospect for the game but had a few weaknesses?

Just throwing this out there, but how good would it be if he was to score the winner against the pies in the semi?

He's at Widnes now, on loan.

I personally don't think he will make it at the top level of the game. Similar to how Nicky Royle went..

I hope he proves me wrong.

He wouldn't be able to play in challenge cup.

he wouldnt be aloud to play! read the link

He will be injured by then anyway.

Really weird signing imo, no idea what Tony Smiths thinking

Sorry

, would of been ace though!

Im baffled your back look fine, Mathers Hicks Grix Riley King Bridge etc.

Why get Carney?



As a big fan of his im glad hes back in the game but it puzzles me why wire would need/want him

Must admit I'm a little baffled by this one.

I wonder if Smith wants him for his contribution in the dressing room, and to help develop the likes of Riley?

If anything wouldnt it keep Riley out? Giving him abit of a coaching role would help the development of him, not signing him as a player

Yep I agree, as I said I'm baffled by it. Who knows, he may just be in there as a squad player to cover for injuries. Maybe his plan is to get Grix and Johnson in the back row, therefore needing back up at three quarters.

Don't let it worry you. Its not Wigan.

Christ.

Tony Smith could sign Ronan Keating and I'd trust him (Smith, not Keating).

on the guardian website it says that monaghans injured his shoulder, maybe this could be quite serious therefore making bridge go into the halves and bringing hicks into centre freeing up a wing space for carney, thats the only thing i can think of but its an odd one for me.

Grix is a forward,so is Johnson when he is fit and Riley isn't good enough imo if we have aspirations of winning something he is ok as a back up to fill in ,in an emergency but never fills me with confidence ,Carney is a far better winger and would imo be a good signing,same as Mathers is a better fullback than Riley which imo leaves Riley as a back up squad player
a back line of
1)Mathers
2)Hicks
3)Bridge
4)King
5)Carney
6)Briers
7)Monaghan
is pretty good imo
our bench would improve with Johnson on it as well

i hope tony smih aint a member on here

See Long leaving is now official. Can't wait for the reaction on this site when they hear who is replacing him at Saints.

Eastmond?

I hear Briers is on his way there. Not sure where i picked that up, probably on here.

www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2009/ju ... l-transfer

www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2009/ju ... l-transfer

we already know

Monaghan?

heres another one i pulled out of the history books,all will be over duly revealed shortly,in the meantime i suggest you listen to inside no knowledge or latchford wolverine whatever he's called.plenty of people will confirm what i said back in april,i have had a little sabbatical laughing at some of the rubbish that has been spouted on here(sinfield,hicks to unuion!)but beleive me i won't even hint anything ever again,happy speculating.

latchy didn't.