But Inglis was never fit and had come out of retirement. Its not as though he stank the place out, he just didn’t play.

David Kidwell, Tony Tatupu, John Wilshire, Steve and Mark Jackson, Willie Swann, Pepe Marquet, Kris Watson, Adam Doyle,

Does the name Manoa Thompson ring any bells?

Hence my agreement he was one of our worst ever overseas signing.
He wasn’t even a shadow of his former self.

Don't forget the immense Leilani Latu.....what an impact he had.........

Then RD shouldn’t the prop from Brisbane who was injured for the whole season (can’t remember his name) be included?

Absolutely.

Mitchell Dodd the prop who was just constantly injured, he goes on the bench I think. Asotasi and maybe even rauhihi go in before him? Rauhihi wasn't terrible but his performances didn't match his reputation at all. Danny Lima can go on for me too, his run around the stands High fiving kids at the end was the most running he did for us. First performance against Wakefield in the first game at the HJ he looked brilliant, but did nothing after that from what I can recall. I suppose that 1 performance does make it a bench spot, no way he goes in ahead of asotasi.

John Wilshere gets a spot for me, I was excited about his signing but he just wasn't very fast, or agile, or good.

Inglis just didn't work out, but a gamble worth taking and I bet he was good to have around the place. He doesn't get on the worst overseas 17 for me.

Wilshere was permanently injured, and got released on medical grounds, I doubt anyone could have an opinion on his form for warrington.

He had a steady couple of years at Salford though

They played him at fullback and it freed him up, we stuck him out on the wing. He didn’t get much ball but didn’t he fare higher than most in the Wire try scoring chart?

"Dead dog" Duffy
"Doc"Murray

Luther Burrell? A failed experiment on the cap and I'm not blaming him or the club in this regard

Is he overseas?

Mateaki Mafi for the vacant wing spot.? Quick but not necessarily with the ball and had a defensive game which was fine unless he had to actually tackle someone.

Apologies, I misread the thread

Is there an argument that Henare could be in both the best and the worst?

Where's Tyrone Roberts? Another marquee misfit!

and hardest

'"

'"

My attendance was more miss than hit during that time…childcare…

If there was a “most exciting” team, he’s be in with a shout. He was one of those players that when he got the ball the terrace took a collective breath almost in expectation of something to happen.

Just for you we can have a most #5 exciting team.
Not particularly great players.

I wouldn't have Steve Georgiallis on there.

I remember people being annoyed when we signed him, as we already had the image of being the retirement home for ageing Aussies and it seemed like an underwhelming signing to make up for Campion changing his mind on us. But in the handful of games he played, he put in a good shift.

I also think Tyrone Roberts was so-so rather than being abysmal. He suffered from pre-season hype and that youtube montage which had us thinking we were getting a game breaking superstar. But the most positive period of the Steve Price era was when we had Roberts at halfback.

Two players from around the Georgallis era who could be nominated for this team would be Anthony Swann and Leon Felton.

Swann was one of the short term loan signings we brought in in the post-DVDV part of 2001. I remember him being absolutely worked over by Bradford when they put 80 odd on us.

Felton was one of those Aussie juniors who qualified as an EU player through family heritage so was off quota, there was a bit of hype about him because he'd been on Saints books the year before. But he looked like basically a student player finding himself in the pros and was well out of his depth.

How memories fade. Roberts did not do himself any favours by looking permanently like he did not want to be here due to homesickness.