i wanted thaler..

Since Thursday night, Thaler has been under house arrest, and is not allowed near any windows with undrawn curtains, should any Stains fans want to do an Edward Fox in Day Of The Jackal.

It would have been worth having Thaler just to hear Eddie's reaction.

The culmination of the season, the biggest game of the season, the final to decide the Super League Champions 2016 should be reffed by the best ref available. Hicks!

One of the best i have seen this year is Gareth Hewer , who reffed Wembley.

Its an absolute joke , 2 years ago they would not even give him a sky live game , he has not improved and whilst the standard overall has gone downhill i can only think of Child and Cobb who are worse

Should have been Hewer. Bentham is good, even if a bit egotistical. I've also rated Campbell.

Hicks, Thaler, Childs are all too full of themselves - faux Clattenbergs without the ability.

Puts tin hat on.

I think we currently have the best roster of referees, in my RL watching lifetime.

Compare them with

a. The outandout bias of the late 70's to mid 80's, with the likes of Kershaw, Campbell, Robin (very apt) Whitfield and the biggest ladies pocket of them all, Biased Billy Thompson.

b. The incompetance of Colin Morris and the Connolly twa...I mean twins, and the bias of John Smith.

c. The arrogance of the likes of Cummins, Klein, Ganson and Ronnie(press-ups in front of the South Stand) Laughton .

As in the words of Harold McMillan,[i=#FF0000you've never had it so good[/i

I have to gloss past a and B, whilst I was watching (since, 1989) I was too young to understand refereeing incompetence really, but I would agree with you from as far back as I can remember. To be fair I think the standard of refereeing has improved this season but there is still a long way to go before it can be considered good, in fact there is a long way to go before it can be considered adequate.

how dare you..youve left out stan wall

I had considered including Wall. I never really had a problem with him, until he appeared in a Stains tracksuit, running on with a sand bucket/kicking tee.

Likewise, the world's favourite pantomime villain, John Holdsworth, and Russell (he cost me £250) Smith

now you have peed me off mentioning that baffoon russell i love wigan smith .... billy thomo was the worst ive ever seen..still go to counselling over that hull cup game down here..

The counsellors have barred me. Still bearing the emotional scars of THAT burglary

You forgot Lindop :-X

Ahhhh the delightful Fred'll Fix It

Christ Russell Smith, the name alone brings a cold shudder down my spine.

..and of course we can't forget Kevin Allatt, he of WW III fame.

Russell Smith! Arrrrrrrgggggggghhhhhhhhhhh! I had to have hypno therapy to erase him from my memory...now it all comes flooding back....where are those pie eaters that were complaining about the decision that didn't suit the stains last week? Grrrrrrrrrrrr

The best John Holdsworth
The worst Billy Thompson

I remember Ronnie Laughton having a police escort off the pitch at Leeds when he reffed us out of the game one Friday night.

Bob and John Connolly. Argh.

Then of course there was Sgt Major Eric Clay whose one redeeming feature was that he hated Australians and Heppethwaite, the only ref to ever send Parry Gordon off.

And don't forget Mick Naughton and Elvis Presley

On this of all weeks was it necessary to mention the undead?

There was also our very own karl kirkpatrick