Spot on Westwood should of gone but so should those 2...whats the point of banning them all they'll miss is a pointless international game or pre season run about...you can't have 2 sets of rules just because it's a final

charnley should have 2 aswell as Linehams elbow on Manfredi? no?

Should he????I'm sure the rfl would have had them had it been a worthwhile ban......

yeah cos they are consistant .....

No they're two completely different incidents Charnley did not slide in knee first....

Pieman, pieman, pieman... Don't you realise that only other teams are guilty of foul play and that the very same disciplinary whose consistency they've complained about all year is now the yardstick by which even handedness is measured? Get with the program man!

What do you mean look who's heads were split open, stitched and bandaged? That's irrelevant. The disciplinary said it was from fair challenges and that should be an end to it! Elbows? Knees? It simply couldn't have been...

Has anyone got the clips of Tomkins x2, Leuluai x1 and Charnley x1. I’m not sure what the incident regarding Leuluai was.
Still waiting to hear what went on in the tunnel (near me they were shouting Escare had started something, but not sure how reliable they were as didn’t seem to have ever watched a game before [although they may well have been to numerous matches).

That Escare looks a right niggly git.

he was clapping the wire fans for throwing bottles at them, then wore players started pushing him and navarette run over to defend him

Sam is a sneaky so and so. We've seen the film of him at the bar with Joel. Full on gobby till he sees the camera.

On Saturday the trip on Goodwin was a trip. Contact with his leg before any attempt with his arms. Sky TV were there, if you've taped it, take a look. Use pause.

He hit Clark with his knee when he clearly could have avoided it. It was a cheap shot and disgusting.

If you play the Charnley 'knee' incident slowly, three things become apparent. 1. Escare (aka rat garcon nouveau) slides into Charnley 2. who isn't moving - his leg remains in the same position throughout- and 3. Escare strikes a glancing blow halfway between knee and foot (this explains why Charnley hasn't received a ban - it was nothing like equal to Tomkins on Clark)

Hicks bottled it pure and simple.

Samkins will no doubt be a flop in France as he was in NZ. After this payday he'll return with his long pink tail between his legs to the piedome to coach the 'Wigin way'.

What I'm surprised hasn't been mentioned too is the cheeky hand in the face Tomkins gave to Charnley, after touching down for his try.

How did Roberts get a fracture ?

Dropped his wallet on his foot ?

Oh...that'll be when he was showing us his backside

salty much

No argument huh?

Shame. Such meek acceptance wasn't what I expected. You should support your team as much as you can before the embarrassment kicks in and chokes you.

Nevermind. Life after the enema will be less morally difficult. You'll never be properly clean, but heck, enjoy the progress

I already told you but you just seem to ignore it. Your actually even blaming Escare for Charnley going in on him. I suspect the elbow from Lineham was Manfredis fault.....your just a tad thick like the tools who threw bottles at our players but then again that was their own fault aswell eh...jog on fella.

'tad thick'?

Ouch. If only you knew it was 'you're' and not 'your' then your jibe would carry more weight.

Oh and you're wrong, I didn't blame Escare, I simply pointed out the two incidents were different.

You're wasting your time, he can't see the incidents were totally different because it doesn't suit his Wigan tinted glasses agenda. The ref definitely bottled it, however, it's doubtful it would have changed the outcome of the final. The charnley incident wasn't even reviewed at Redhall because there was nothing in it.

He is the Wigan version of LeBron, don't feed the troll.

Imagine a wire player doing what they did and just getting a talking to..na they'd be off straight away...

Dont worry about it kids, wait till next season when he slides in on Williams or Manfredi after they score against catalans, theyll join the club then.

Never liked, wasn't happy when we re-signed him after his failed attempt in the NRL, He should have gone at least once

Very good point...and he won't get away with it as often.....

like Westwood oh hold on.....