Serioulsy come on!!!

Our side is poor yet yours is worse which by my logic means we'd get more in a combined team surely?

Of course.

We're pi*s weak at prop yet your strong and i'd say were better in the outside backs and backrowers and about level at halfback.

End of the day neither side is good enough and we all know it.

I will even put the side by side for you to compare
1. Stuart Reardon 1.ritchie Mathers
2.Chris hicks 2.Pat Richards
3. Martin Gleeson 3.George Carmont
4.Paul Johnson 4.Darrell Goulding
5.Matt King 5.Amos Roberts
6. Lee Briers 6.Thomas Leuluai
7. Michael Monaghan 7.Sam Tompkins (should be Tim Smith )
8. Adrian Morley 8.Stuart Fielden
9. Micky Higham 9.Mark Ridell
10. Paul Rauhihi 10.Andy Coley
11. Louis Anderson 11.Gareth Hock
12. Ben Westwood 12.Phil Bailey
13. Vinnie Anderson n 13.Shaun o'laughlin

14. John Clarke 14.Tim Smith
15. Paul Wood home 15.Joel Tompkins
16. Gareth Carvell 16.Pallinya
17.Ben Harrison 17.Harrison Hansen

Which 11 are better then Nickykiss do ya best then and tell us what makes them better

So basically what you're saying is that our record signing might be going to a rival club but that, because you can't be bothered, you're not going to pick up the phone to find out, even though you are very well connected?

Fair play to you Latchy, I'd be on that phone like a shot! Sadly, I don't have any inside information. You must have the patience of a saint.

Any news on the Sinfield signing by the way?

Thats not our starting 17.

1. Stuart Reardon 1. Pat Richards
2.Chris hicks 2. Amos Roberts
3. Martin Gleeson 3.Phil Bailey
4.Paul Johnson 4.George Carmont
5.Matt King 5. Sean Ainscough
6. Lee Briers 6. Sam Tomkins
7. Michael Monaghan 7. Thomas Leuluai
8. Adrian Morley 8.Stuart Fielden
9. Micky Higham 9. Mark Ridell
10. Paul Rauhihi 10.Andy Coley
11. Louis Anderson 11.Gareth Hock
12. Ben Westwood 12.Harrison Hansen
13. Vinnie Anderson 13. Sean O'Loughlin

14. John Clarke 14. Micky McIlorum
15. Paul Wood 15.Joel Tomkins
16. Gareth Carvell 16. Feka
17.Ben Harrison 17. Paul Prescott

ones in bold id prefer (this is going off current form because obviously matt king on his nrl form is better than ainscough at the moment.)

That Wigan side isn't the side I, Noble or most other would pick so going off my own plus your Wire team my combined side would be-

Richards
Hicks
Gleeson
Carmont
Ainscough
S Tomkins
Leuluai
Morley
Riddell
Carvell
Hock
Westwood
O'Loughlin

subs
Paleaaesina
Fielden
J Tomkins
Higham

Theres my 11 wiganers(maybe 12 if Gleeson signs

) and i can honestly say hand on heart i don't know which other Wire player would get in.

King and Monaghan would on top form but we all know they've come nowhere near and a team should be picked on form.

one word.........BLINKERED.

Maybe so but would you say a wire fan saying that you'd only take Richards, Tomkins and Hock would be classed the same?

We'd surely get at least an even share.

I suppose a neutral would give the best indication.

As a neutral, I'd rather have Riddell as our food tester than our hooker.

I'm sorry Emma, but i had to stop taking notice after that. The rest aren't too far off though

That's the worst kop out I've ever heard on here

"I pick and choose my inside information"

Not blinkered just delusional .

tbh bar McIlorum who has potential, the other 3 hookers are all shocking at the moment, i just went for Riddell because i dont think people have given him a fair chance yet to settle in, and he is actually playing better at wigan now than Higham ever did.

AS I SAID BEFORE 3 WITH ONE ABOUT EVEN

Not basing Higham on his past performances but Riddell on his current are we my dear?

This would be likie swapping a Ferrari (Martin Gleeson) for 2 run arounds that have failed their MOT and combined wouldn`t add up to much more than a hundred quid.

This is obviously an early April fools as nobody in their right mind would have Mathers or Goulding never mind swap them for Martin Gleeson.

this is why this kind of thing shouldnt be done Ben Harrison if he carries on like he has been, can easily become player of the year at warrington....

I have never heard of Paul Prescott nor seen him play I can only assume you are in the same boat with regards to Ben Harrison....

Quite correct ,maybe they should be touting them to Widnes ,with Cullen and his midas touch he can turn them into wallets or market traders .

Too true.
Goulding could be usefull and Gleesons on his way anyway.
I'd still rather have Gleeson for the rest of this season than swap now tbh, but pleeease stick him back at 3

ok base both on past and i'd still have riddell

Higham -
Good Scooter, Fast over 100m, Has Passion

Cant Pass, Cant Organise, Loses his head when the going gets tough, Loads of Penaltys, Poor Ball Handling, Not Powerfull Enough.

Riddell -
Excellent distribution, Organises round the field well, Powerful close to line, Scoots well but not as good as Higham,

Overweight erm...thats it.

Higham only has one thing to his game, Riddell is the better all round player.

In Goulding I reckon yor getting a reasonable player but Mathers

I'd try to get a decent back-rower from Wigan, maybe Hansen.

Done deal.
Due to be announced on Wednesday.

How long have you been watching Rugby League?

Think what he means is he is crap but we could give him a job with heathcotes serving at the beer kiosk

If you do it that way, i could probably come up with some good stuff on Mathers, means tosh now though.

Try again, but on current form, something Riddell hasn't found yet