Are you not being judgemental there ?

He is not being judgemental saying he was disgusted and revolted by Monaghan's cannine abuse. If that is how he feels, that is how he feels. He was not "judging" Monaghan.

It was revolting and he was rightly sacked for it and everyone deserves a 2nd chance don't they? (Well apart from Hitler, Pol Pot and Bin Laden).

Worse things happen on Mad Monday most years.

These guys give up a lot to play professionally and it is inevitable they might get a bit crazy when let off the leash. No pun intended!

Exactly .................. I was not judging Monaghan, merely stating that I found his actions repugnant, and did not relish being reminded of them.

Not many would disagree with you on here. He was caught dog-bothering afterall.

But I'd happily see him back in the P&B. Not the fastest anymore, but probably still one of the best natural try scorers in super league. His stats don't lie.

As a centre perhaps?

He was great and 145 tries from 145 apps is a fantastic return, but IMHO we're not short of wide players for 2016, and would rather we all moved forwards.

Why not? They gave George W Bush a 2nd chance even after he lost the election!

Ah your the old fashioned type ...?

Much more comfortable with wife beaters. Drink drivers, drug takers,

Much more acceptable to have numerous of the above "badges of honour" than let a dog lick your nob when you are drunk as at a Rugby bash...

Monas is a model bloke he made one embarrassing mistake . that didn't harm anyone nor had the potential to harm anyone.....
or the dog if anyone is that stupid to think a dog was "harmed"

Pathetic post pal...

lets face it, we've all let a few dogs lick our nob.

I am sure there are many members of the rugby league "family" with skeletons in the cupboard. In his shorter career Zak Hardaker has been much more controversial than Joel .

Erm.........

This has so made my day.

I don't condone wife beating, drunk driving, or drug taking ........................ And to be honest, I'm not that comfortable with people who can't spell "you're."

To be fair I'm not comfortable with people who mistake people's skill at swipe texting messages on a small samsung phone with predictive text turned on for their actual spelling capabilities.

Criticise my proof reading by all means.... i don't know where you rank that on your revulsion list ....but I don't give too

s to be honest...

I see what you did there

Aaahhhhh. The Mississippi Showboat. What a shame that was burnt down.

To be fair, after an £17 'all you can drink' promotion those dogs looked mighty pretty...

Signed for Castleford according to nosey Parker.

local press in Cas reporting that I think..somebody posted a newspaper clipping on facebook.

Isn't Carney staying there? If so they've got Solomona on the other wing, can't see them needing him unless they're planning to stick him at centre as I believe Webster is out of contract.

Signed for us for 2 years. Reckon this will mean Carney will be leaving us. Webster is supposedly staying for a year aswell.

Just seen it confirmed on sky sports news, a 2 year deal.

Also in the WA Guardian, all the best Joel it was a pleasure to see you play.

According to the BBC, he scored 141 tries in 143 appearances for us. Lies I tell you! www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/34637507

According to the BBC, he scored 141 tries in 143 appearances for us. Lies I tell you! www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/34637507