Terribly decision.

I cant believe this guy is rated as one of the best in SL.

Phelps was taken out so it is simply not a try. If that would of been the other way around you would agree.

Even if Saints get there???

may av to watch that again when sober...but as ed as i was i know a forward pass i.e. that overated tool sam tompkins...it was yards forward even you`ll agree with that

Last year??

It was forward but Sam Tomkins is not overated, he is just rated highly as a great young payer.

No doubt he will be young player of the year. Don't judge him on one game, he has been great in games you probably havn't even seen, he is still young so will only get better.

he did his very best to let wigan back in the game at every opportunity.

shocking display.

he didnt even think about going to the video for the tomkins try.

That is all partly due to the hype of Eddie and Stevo though, treating him as their latest love child, as they do with every young player when they first come onto the scene. There have been some games where he has been fairly poor, as he was today, but listening to them two muppets you would think he was the man of the match.

what could he go to the video for ?

Before he even played in super league most wigan fans had seen him in the reserves and knew how good he was. Eddie and stevo just go with the majority and most people think Tomkins is a good player.

I have heard it all now. Dont talk daft

Again, another game where it was pointless having touch judges, either not used or useless.

For what? You can't go to the video ref for a forward pass.

Ganson looked up with the play,but still kept looking over to the touch judge who was yards behind,,very strange....like some one said sympathy call......

He was his usual "not fit for purpose" today but you won and the rest is history enjoy it!!

Doesn't make it right.

I once did a bit of refereing, i was told that if a player loses control of the ball because of injury it was a scrum to the team that had possesion. Now that was a few years ago so it might have changed but ganson did get it wrong saying tackle complete before he lost control, however if the rule stillexist that i mentioned warrington should have had head and feed at the scrum. Ganson did make a few balls up though (from a warrington view) allowing the Tomkins try from a forward pass and refering to the video ref after blowing for a knock on.

Blowing his whistle then going to the video ref to see if a "try" was scored after he had blown (and stopped play) should be enough to get him demoted to amateur RL for a month. Because it's Ganson he'll get away with it. A truly unforgivable error on a rugby pitch by a ref. The Amos Roberts "knock forward" was about the only thing he didn't refer to the video ref. If he had it would have been obvuious the ball went forward 5 yards. Again, a major error.

How much longer will players and spectators have to suffer this arrogent T@ doing what he likes on the field without any comeback?

Watched it all recorded from TV now.

Ganson had a good game on the whole - although the Tomkins try was a mile forward - although the vid ref can't look at that Ganson should have got it.

if you feel so strong about it why not give stuart cummings a call , i am sure he would love to hear from budding referees like yourself!!

What am I incorrect about? Can you can answer that smart ar$e?

didnt say you were incorrect, if you think you could do better take up the whistle, you have nothing to lose, then maybe we could all criticise you .

Oy! Why try and ruin the start of the amateur season by forcing him on us?

lock it,ganson is a useless wige,end of.

Just watched the game back and that decision where they Ganson went to the video ref after already blowing the whistle was a joke. Its a good job Chris Bridge played on after the whistle, otherwise the try would have been given.

The way he spoke to the players when they rightly questioned how he could do something so ridiculous was so arrogant.