It is a double edge sword. Thaler is lax around the ruck and Morgan is a widge who always moans.

When we played HKR down here a few weeks ago, he bemoaned the amount of penalties his team conceded, despite winning the penalty count.

Did anyone see that mook behind the sticks near the west stand? He looked like he had just come from the Lord Rodney after a dinner time session. When Bentham asked him about Morley's effort he didn't have a clue and Morley nearly landed on him. What a waste of space.

As i'm edging (ahem) towards middle-age can you explain WTF a "mook" is.

Actually, he got that decision spot on, I think the discussion was around whether Hudds had made the first knock on. From lip reading, it looked like the ref said something like 'well done' to the in goal judge, as the linesman agreed with his call.

It's just a word that I can't get banned for saying!!!! I guess you never saw him then? He was walking like Rab C Nesbit and not even in line with play.

he was not even at the game so i would not take his comment seriously. No major complaints from me about the reffing

I thought he had a good game - didn't get a great deal of help from his Touch Judges though. I thought both teams had tries that should have been disallowed for forward passes.

I thought it was interesting that Bentham pinned Huddersfield first tackle for lying on - sort of set the tone for the rest of the game. All that whining people have been doing about the Giants is bound to have an effect, even if its only subconsciously.

No your right, i wasnt at the game, but im still entitled to my opinion just like the next person, this is a discussions board after all!!