Mathers for me.

not sure you went to this game ,higham had his hand in about 4 trys .take your time clarky

2nd in the league my mate so carnt be doing much wrong can they ,every games different dont you think carnt play well evry game ,thats sport ,or have you never played any with that silly post

Kingy for me. defence was epic - 110% as always and not much getting past him.

What is it with his errant passing? He's a pro RL player with all week to work on making sure his passes don't go above forwards' heads from acting half.

t,s likes the pass to the face so it makes your hands come up

Louis for me, closely followed by Mathers who had his best game in P&B.

Thought hookers did a good job in the conditions. I think both monas and higham are class

Irrelevant whether I've played or not. I thought we needed speeding up yesterday. However, once Higham came on, he started his wayward passing again. I just think we'd do well with Clarke's control, then Monaghan bursting on after 30 minutes or so.

stick to dominos ,it realy wanted speeding up in the rain ,clarke to start next week iv been told and monas come in on to speed up some were

Maybe speeding up was the wrong phrase. A bit more direction is what I wanted.

I wouldn't play Clarke until the Fev game if he is fit enough. Think he will need a few second string games before he starts pushing for a spot in the 17.

I went for Mathers but special mention must go to the Salford coaching staff for making Alker take the shots at goal from the penalties, particularly the second one. Lovely sense of humour.

Monas in the second half, was much better than Monas in the first half. His kicking from dummy half was especially top notch, he's a settling presence we need on the field I feel.

That's a good call that ref the kicking, and forgotten about that. I think that's what Smith was referring to when spoke about 'understanding the conditions' better in the second half, we got our forward going forward then Monaghan kicked well from DH.

That's what sets apart from Higham, well, as well as the other stuff that he's much better at, but the option he has from DH to kick is excellent. We scored from one of his kicks, it was fielded - Broughton spilt it coming back with ball in hand and Solomona scored under the posts.

His kicking is much better from hooker than it ever was as a halfback, similar to his game in general.

No he didn't.

oooowwwwww yes he did

No really, I was there in reality & I've seen the highlights since, he didn't. Once Clarke is back, he'll be dropped I think.

I have to disagree, I think higham has been great so far coming on from the bench. Whilst Clarkey may be a bit more accurate, his snail pace from bending over,picking up the ball, standing up, looking both ways, then passing has really slowed us down in previous seasons.

Having 2 quick hookers with pace to break the line from DH has worked great so far. I fancy Clarkey as more if a ball playing loose forward myself. Has a good kicking game too and give us another good option

Few saints fans have said our squad isn't big enough / lacks quality, I think our selection headaches prove em wrong! In smith we trust...

Second in the league, if it ain't broke, don't fix it!!

no honest really honest really he wont be dropped really honest .you need a reality kick up the ass i think realy honest

louis for me. thought carvell and westwood had their worst games of the season IMO

Definitely, he is twice the player he is when he plays at DH compared to halfback, his kicking especially has impressed me from DH. He was unlucky not to at least get one forty-twenty, having such a good kicking outlet not only from DH but in general apart from the halfbacks gives us alot more options, its good to see as you generally don't get that with many hookers in Super league.

Monas has just got in team of the month you numpty!! Shows how well you read the game....

It's all opinions, isn't it.

Obviously not.

Louis for me too on the basis that he ran and tackled really strongly and didn't produce his usual 'rush out of the line and leave a huge gap, knock on under no pressure, throw silly passes or give away needless penalties' type of game. Thought he lived up to his potential for once.