Such is the life of a massive club, even guys that are proven winners elsewhere sometimes stumble in the bright lights of the big time and expectations are high so reputations count for little here if you don't deliver success. It happens at United, Real Madrid, Dallas Cowboys and in RL its us.

Proven winners that took over a SL club while peaking and took the steadily backwards and/or at least into off-field disrepute, Millward Noble McDermott, I’d say Wane did so too just avoiding the middle eights over Smiths Wire, redeeming some credit after with a GF.
I wouldn’t be looking at any of the ‘proven’ GF winners from above, but those who have excelled under limited resources, I’ve made no secret of John Kear, but you could perhaps add Powell, Anderson, Watson, you could argue a case for Luke Robinson and Andrew Henderson....if I had a magic wand it would have to be Trent Robinson, but I’d be almost as pleased with John Kear, you just cannot fault the guys record as much as the stick I get for it.

his record being?

I was nodding along in agreement and then came to John kear! Powell, Anderson and Watson have all done fantastic jobs at getting the best from their players and budget at their disposal and brought relative success to their clubs. I don't think mcdermott or wane could have done what those 3 managed at the clubs they were at. I fully agree go for Powell, Watson would have been great IMO, I think Anderson would do a job, all depends whether he wants it again really though, same with Henderson. The other problem with promoting from within is whether the players respond as well as they would if they had to impress someone they didn't know.

but Not John Kear.

His underdog cup wins at Sheffield and Hull and a superb record at Wakefield when he took over on a hiding to nothing and with little resources and permanent off field instability made them a competitive team.

When a coach gets multiple teams to punch above their weight he's probably a good coach.

John Kear!? You'll be suggesting Karl Harrison next.

No I won’t.

Do us a favour, can you give me a year by year breakdown of his career, since, say, start of SL, including, trophies, relegations, promotions, sackings, club and international, just for consideration.

How far back are we going? The bloke is 66 years old now and has been coaching in the Championship for the last 10 years and last won something over 16 years ago?

May as well appoint Tony Rae because he did a decent job at London!

2019 6th, 2020 7th at time of season suspension (4 games played only)

There are only two current SL coaches with a Grand Final win on the CV. I doubt we'll get Woolf from St Helens, so would the Hull KR coach be worth a punt? Multiple trophy winner (SL, CC, WCC), entertaining rugby, international coaching experience. Sounds ideal for us.

Going back to duckie's obsession with a certain coach....

You want a RL equivalent of Sam Allardyce to come and turn us around? Kear is now a "firefighter". I'm sorry duckie. I like the majority of your posts, but you're going back to your attention seeking worst, here.

You're a spoilsport

Based on what Leigh are doing to Wigan, maybe we should have appointed Duffy.

As for Mr Kear, well I've had some great afternoons in the cup (my 1990 Wembley outfit brought gasps from the neighbours), I'm frequently incomprehensible and my best years are also 30 years behind me so you might as well appoint me. I'm probably more expensive than Kear though, and rightly so.

You'd be in front of Kear in my list. Biggest doubt on your appointment would be the EU blocking the movement of HBC.

Obviously very early days, but Hodgson looks to have Hull very nicely set up; still plenty of size and aggression but playing some nice football, with a freedom and ease that bodes well for them.

Watson's Huddersfield look very ponderous in comparison.

I'll not read anything into hull till at least ten games in.

They took Leeds to the cleaners in last seasons opener, and everyone went ott

Nope as Powell is actually a very good coach who can actually coach a team and motivate his players. Price couldn't run a bath let alone a professional rugby team.