As it looks like Hicks is leaving, with Riley and King probably being first choice wings, should we sign another winger for next season?? Any thoughts?? My suggestion is perhaps Craig Calvert of Whitehaven

good call has he got much top flight experience................?

Based on 40 minutes from the Widnes game?

I think Penny needs to be given another chance.

We tried to sign Calvert in 2003/4.

It will take a huge player to replace Hicks.

I need we need a class winger from the NRL.

We can't as no room on the quota. Please don't ask or otto be explained as it has been so many times before it gets boring.

Although I agree we need a top quality finisher as Hicksy will be a huge loss!

Surely we have moved on from Craig Calvert. As noted above, he was in Cull's sights early on in his reign.

We got rhys williams and penny

greatest curve ball ever if smith plays penny when hicks leaves.

You are not wrong. Hicks is a superb finisher. I don't get the Riley love in (he reminds me of the ginger winger who played for Saints and then dissapeared) and also think King is better in the centre position. Class winger required please. Together with a 13, then we have a team to challenge.

Indeed a class aaussie winger from the NRL & and a ball playing 13 I'd like to think our team would be near perfect.

Probs because he is a young Warrington lad and a good finisher also has abit of skill about him as well as that Bradford try last season showed.

Someone posted on our board that both Wigan and Warrington had made a bid for [url=http://www.melbournestorm.com.au/default.aspx?s=player-profile-display&id=332&team=StormAnthony Quinn[/url

Why not let Tony Smith decided. He is paid to do the job and so far is doing everything right,

you can't just have all the best players in your team thats what the salary cap is there for, leeds and saints don't have all world class players such as kirke, ablett, hargreaves and paul clough

to answer the original question - no.

I'm pretty sure our quota situation would preclude us from that.

Maybe Rhys Williams will step up.

Never - that's why I said would be perfect.

I want Fa'afili back!!!!!!!

Backward step, too old, can't hold his place at Leeds RU.

I`d say that we do need a winger, replacing Hicks with Riley on the right obviously weakens us from what we had this year. Thats no disrespect to Chris Riley, its just that Chris Hicks's boots are large boots to fill.

A winger from Australia or New Zealand is out of the question due to our quota being full, we wouldn`t have a chance with Ryan Hall so i`d try and tempt Hull with some money for Tom Briscoe.

i used to love his backwards step.

dave halley done deal apparently

Where are these Classy wingers from Australia ?
In the very classy state of Origin, Full back Darius Boyd and Centre Israel Folau were the Queensland "wingers" While Fullback Jarryd Hayne played on the wing for NSW in game 1.

I suppose a like for like replacement for Hicks would be Luke Burt at the Eels.... a good Steady pro no Represenative honours to speak of a but can cover wing and fullback and can goal kick...

is that what we class as "classy" ?

I'd rather have Brett Morris now he is class....