Carney starting on saturday. Tony Smith has just informed us at the forum

Instead of ?

riley. (apparently)

bit strange to announce the team for the biggest game of our season(in terms of crowd and rivalry and excitment) at a fans forum before the squad is even announced.

Why? Riley has played well in the past few games & certainly doesn't deserve to get dropped

Did Smith confirm this?!? I have a txt saying Carney will start on Saturday from a friend who has been tonight but he did say he didnt give a reason. Hicks is possibly carrying his injury still, maybe he needs a week or two out.

Get Smith out............

Thats more of a reason. Did TS give any other team news?

Unless Chris Riley is injured then this to me is a strange switch if true, firstly Chris Riley has been playing well and he`s also performed well against Saints in the past, surely if their was a game to bring Brian Carney into the team then it was against Celtic Crusaders last weekend.

If Chris Riley has a knock then fair enough, if he hasn`t then its a little unfair to drop a player for such a big game who has been in decent form.

So many questions you all could have asked!!

Very Very good night, funny and insightful Tony Smith is the real deal, comes across very well and very knowledgeable.

tony smith never confirmed who carney is replacing whether it will be hicks or riley. The only reason TS confirmed carney will be playing is because he said it will be in the warrington guardian tomorrow.

I am not sure as he also stated at the begining that the team wasn't selected until tomorrow.

Red Herring?

I'm partial to a bit of mackerel myself

You would know wouldnt you!

I got the impression that he was being sincere ref Carney. I think Riley will miss out.

i trust geordie... no more

Todays made up fact !


Fact really is TS implied nothing as to who Carney would play in place of !

Keep the opposition guessing and the supporters, eh.



Wouldn't say its nailed on Riley. There is no reason why Hicks couldn't shift inside at centre, so Riley could still play. Decisions, decisions.

did nobody pick up on tony smith saying about players covering many different positions,he mentioned hicks playing in the centres previously?
could we be swapping winger for winger or are there plans afoot...........

You stole my idea!

Aha! He didn't have a tache.

Go on Brian, many times i've see him do somethin magic against saints, hope he pulls out the same tricks for you lot on sat

Legend.

Hope he doesn`t pull his hamstring which seems to be one of his favourite tricks

i prefer to call it file sharing davy