Released today by hull kr. Haven't read anywhere that he has signed for anyone next year. Is this a player we should be looking at?

Hasn't got great pace but has always stood out in the matches I've seen. Also very good under the high ball both in attack and defence. Excellent goal kicker as a bonus. Thoughts??

A member of a side that got relegated.

Good finisher and great kicker which can make the differance between a win or loss, tho if Patton gets good game time we should be OK on that front


He stood out in a hull kr team would he stand out in a top 4 team I'm not so sure, he would not be an unwelcome addition to the team tho and more cap realistic than other names mentioned.

He's an excellent all round player hasn't got great pace but is a good finisher great under the high ball brings it out well excellent goal kicker rumour is Cas bound

Absolutely not

Why sign another winger.. When we can play a fullback there?

How many tries did he score last year?

A poor mans Pat Richards for me.

he was out injured a lot of last year, only came back late on.

he is a poor mans pat richards but on a reasonable contract he'd be a good addition.

13 games
8 tries
58 goals

I have only seen him play in occasionally like most people on here but everything i have seen has been positive about the lad. A good goal kicker is not something to be sniffed at either.

He uses more bandages than the Invisible Man

I always thought he was a decent player. He had a few injuries last year.

Not that there is any other comparison but so did Brian Bevan by all accounts!

Quite. That's why I would never want to sign a Warrington player because they always choke in big games

Regards

King James

Can't give you an argument

your big game was salford and you well and truely choked..as for montilado no ta couldnt give a hoot as to how many goals he can kick,it would be a massive step backwards as most teams would target his wing

Lebron James is a saints troll

Edited for accuracy

i do apologise must still be on a downer from losing to us in the semi final

They didn't lose they were robbed by a corrupt ref and corrupt SL officials who wanted a new name on the trophy...obviously they forgot to tell the Final ref

Yeah they nearly lost by 4 points instead of 8!

And???

Chris Hill was a member of a side that wasn't even in Super League!

He turned out OK.

Hilly was a young prospect back then not an aging prospector.

Anyway. After reading about a page of petty bickering ( well that's how it comes across to me. If it's reasoned debate I apologise ) any more thoughts about whether Josh Mantellato would be an asset to our team?

Well, I'd have him at Wigan in Sarginsons spot, or Manfredi's til he's fit. As for goalkicking, we dont even know who ours is yet for next season