Ok so last night put to bed, what's your 17 for Huddersfield?

Russell
Lineham
Evans
Atkins
Penny
Patton
Gidley
Hill
Clarke
Sims
Currie
Hughes
Westerman

Ratchford
Westwood
Cox
Julien

Would be mine, however just going through it then I thought of plenty of changes depending on who is/isn't fit.

Russell
Lineham
Evans
Atkins
Penny
Ratchford
Gidley
Hill
Clark
Sims
Currie
Hughes
Westerman

Westwood
Jullien
Cox
King

Ratchford was fine last night, half backs are never going to stand out if set completion is so poor. He set up 2 tries and looked to have a decent kicking game. We need to be far better with our completion rate.

Jack Hughes needs to start a game from the bench I think.

He was very poor yesterday.... I'd reward Benjamin Julien for injecting some go forward into a piddle poor back row.

no room in this squad for people getting complacent and expecting their name in the same spot on the team sheet week in week out....

we've a strong-ish squad we should use it...

After Atkins being put on report do you think he will be available?

No need to panic with team selection ,providing a goal kicker is nominated on Monday morning & is given plenty of practice. Danny Brough won't have any problems next week & we need to be on the ball with kicks since our best attacking asset is injured.

Maybe I shouldn't predict as no one seemed to know about Coxs' injury

Looking at the apparent difficulty TS has with putting a goal kicker in place it makes you wonder if the likes of Ratchford & Gidley are playing with injuries that we don't know about. We could even have quite a few injured players turning out & doing the best they can only to be criticised on this forum for being "not up to scratch".

I really like Jullien as a player; uncompromising, tough and aggressive. I would certainly select him without hesitation.

As you say nine Gidley is carrying an injury so why isn't Ratchford kicking goals if both players who are the main creators are carrying knocks the team can't carry both, if so I don't understand why Patton is not in the frame unless god forbid he's also carrying one, Smith will chance other changes/goal kickers but not put in a like player for player.

Smith is playing the hand he's been dealt with regards to injuries I just feel he shuffles the team a little too much.

I think having 3 or more kickers tells me TS thinks GK are a concern he cares little about. Whereas KC's higher regard for them won the Pikes the game.

I don't think Ryan's tackle was deliberate or calculated. The tackle wasn't completed and the man wasn't on the floor (will check again). I don't think he's that sort of player.

I'd be disappointed if he gets a ban or fine.

I've got to agree fez on all fronts and despite the comedy villain booing from the west when the replay was shown

I'll put my faith in a GF and 3 x CC winning coach, so I wont put my preferred XVII down.

I'm also assuming that he will also address the goal/place kicking issue, after all, that's his job, and he knows a lot more about RL than internet posters. Come to think of it, so does Agar.

A stronger bench needed, we had 2 backs and 2 kids on it v Saints. When are Bailey and BEvans fit?

For me the Friday loss was more frustration than anything because of other options/choices that were available having said that Fridays team had enough personnel to win, so put it down to an off night that's the nature of sport, as you say it's best left to Smith and Agar so far they are going very well, though there are a few disruptive injuries they still have options, things could be a lot worse.

Don't really think the bench was the problem.

I heard Ben was playing but not seen anything of Bailey even getting a reserve match

The infection on Bailey's leg has cleared up and he can now start running again. So I would guess we are looking at 2-3 weeks minimum before he even gets a run out in the reserves. Meanwhile Ben Evans has been playing since the third week in February. He has played twice for the reserves and twice for Rochdale. But... he was injured during March 2015, so he has had a full year out, plus no pre-season so I don't know what sort of player we will get back this season.

I'd be tempted to hand a few rests out:

1. Russell
2. Lineham
3. R Evans
4. Atkins
5. Penny
6. Gidley
7. Patton
8. B Evans
9. Ratchford
10. Cox
11. Currie
12. Westwood
13. Westerman

14. I really want to give Daz a rest. Morgan Smith has played at hooker I think? Dubious.
15. Philbin
16. G King
17. Hughes

After what happened at wakey today I wouldn't rest anybody. Hudds season could start this fri if we don't play to our full potential.

If Gidley shakes this calf issue he has, then he should be kicking Friday. As you say, Brough wont miss many, so we need him back on duty!!

This

I agree and thankfully so do the RFL. No charge for Ryan.

No he hasn't ever played hooker at Warrington.

It would be absolute insanity to rest Clark anyway.

Is it a case of resting players or player management/conditioning Hull and Cats had players out knocks/rested over Easter and are going well while Saints played their fittest team including youngsters against some of our not so fit players and goal kickers and get a win.

No player would thank a coach for resting him for the sake of it players with knocks/strains would accept it so they should if any be the ones to miss out giving others a chance being a team game surely Gidley is not the only one with a brain.

My guess is that TS will play virtually his strongest side again. This year there are no easy games as Wigan recently learned to their cost. Then there is the new format. You have to finish in the top 4 to have the chance of the GF, and that means there is much less margin for error - you have to go for every point during the season. Finally Huddersfield will be desperate for a win and we should expect the kitchen sink to be thrown at us.