On report, what do we think?

Ban or no ban?

Personally, I thought it was a nothing challenge.

no ban defo.

No ban, It wasnt that bad. initial contact his the chest.

Hit the ball and bounced up, no chance of a ban.

I dont think so... Horne made a meal of it

Not even a penalty.

Never in a million years.

Round the chest area.

Ganson wasn't going give it until 5 mintutes later when all the Hull supporters started boo'ing.

Let's hope he doesn't get a ban.

No charge should be the verdict.

No charge would be about right

Nothing in it, he had a great game though.

I thought so, apart from the first 6/7 minutes or so.

No ban. Decent tackle.

Zvonimir No Ban

Absolute joke that he was put on report in the first place..

never in a million years.

See those called as shoulder plenty of times, no ban for mine.

Not even a penalty.

Can Carvell be cited for an offence that he has already been punished for ??

The drop with the forearm for which he was sin binned was by far the worst offence of the 2.

oh yeah, most of the offences on the rfl disciplinary are from reviews after the game.

Poor decision, no penalty. Horne was holding his forehead at one point immediately after the tackle.

That play with the forearm happens every game and rarely gets punished. Ganson was being a right tit. Absolutely shocking decision, although if you were listening to BBC humberside I expect it would have been a hanging offence

Seen far worse.

Not guilty.

.........999,999 years and 365 days later, it still was a fare tackle and wont have a case to answer, but that forearm in the face was there for all to see.

History in the making. A topic everyone agrees on

Two pages long and not a argument in site......

Carvell was defo fired up for this one maybe to much,
think thats why ganson said go and have 10 mins to cool off,
could of cost us but didnt.

Oh his tackle on horne nothing in it,
our lads will take a lot worse than that next week,
hock and oloughlin go for players windpipes every week...

Bring it on...