I agree with the OP; for me it was a clear try. The ball had already gone and Brough made a clear movement to tackle the man, rather than being ran into and fouled? Seemed a cop out.

The problem is this : you could go to any RL game, any team, any ref (includig Thaler) anywhere in the world between now and October and the exact same scenario will be given as a try.

Similarly, if Walmsley moves off the mark tonight will he get pinged like BMM did? No, he'll probably get a penalty for Cas messing around.

Refs and the RFL are trying to make an exact science out of officiating to the point that common sense are dispensed with in favour of obscure laws and unyielding interpretations of the rule.

The rule about players on the floor at the ptb has become a get out of jail free card for players, including our own, to get a dead cert penalty.

Unless a player is deliberately interfering with the ptb or obstructing a player by physically restraining a defender then it should be play on.

They are discussing last nights no try ahead of the Cas game, the word is Hicks had insufficient evidence to overturn Thaler’s decision LMAO.

Eye witness testimony of man with one look at it in real-time trumps opinion of man with several looks at it from various angles and in slow motion

Perhaps specsavers should be binned off in favour test-you-own-specs from Benidorm market.

They're sponsored by Ronseal now, 'It does exactly what it says on the tin'.