The problem is, what other ways can we compare two players? We could look at the players stats last season, that's a full season, not just 2 games. We can't however rely on the opinion of Wigan or Warrington fans because they are obviously going to be biased towards their player.

Well why not use last seasons stats then?

OK here goes

[urlhttp://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2009&hp1=2163&hs2=2009&hp2=1813&stat=tries&season=2010[/url

Looking at that, they seem pretty even. Tomkins had a terrible penalty record and not great on the errors while Harrisons missed tackles aren't that great and he could have done with scoring a few more tries.

I think Harrison's CC winners medal is better than scoring 4 more tries

and Ricky Bibey's *shuddders* two CC winners medals is better again.