I don't suppose you had the balls to tell them what a ridiculous comment it was, and how they should be embarrassed about it did you?



Nah, didn't think so ...

Totally agree HR.

Pointless and v boring.

OK we have a small pack so why dont we have a coach who can instil players to run wide into gaps a la Reg Houldsworth last night - line deeper - so they are running on the ball. Our tactic should be to run the opposition forwards breathless rather than constant barging.

Its the Australian way though isnt it? Tedious fayre.

Agreed - this season, amazingly we have some pace in the backs so why oh why were we playing up the middle being outmuscled instead of swinging it wide?

because the SLUG's gameplan was based on how the Welsh team played against Leeds which was up the middle leaving gaps on the outside and the SLUG did not spot this.

As it happens... the conversation stemmed from me asking why we were so poor. Why they seemed so lazy and uninterested. What there excuses were.... that was the excuse they gave me. I didn't tell them it was a ridiculous comment... but I did ask them what they were going to do about it and said how it wasn't really fair on the fans, and why on earth they expected us to turn up week in week out.

I certainly feel that it's worth the fans knowing what was said and what to expect... and perhaps why we look so poor.

And what did these so called players say they was gonna do about it Loyalfan ?

They didn't answer the question.

Thought more would have been said than that, but hey ho..

Did anyone notice the smug grin on the SLUGS face as he joined the que into our flash 2 foot wide players tunnel!!
Lets me honest he couldnt give 2 foooks deep down inside bout the club we live for!!hiself and father ted over the last few years are really laughing all the way to the bank atthe expense of the club we love..END OF..name anything positive they have done to help take the club forward!!????(dont say a clean sweep in national league as my gran could have coached that team to the glory we had that year!)

I put this on the Pie Eaters forum, they were saying the same about Ian Millward when he was there. If a player or group of players do not perform on the field because they have a problem with the current coach then they should be fined and have their pay docked. They do not play for the coach neither do they get paid by them and as "professional rugby league players" their sole intention should be to win every game for the club that employs them. When they pull on the Salford City Reds shirt on they must put any off field problems behind them or face the wrath of the board. We cannot let player power creep into this sport.

We are !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Agreed players should give 100% regardless of the tool in charge, but you can see why they become this way inclned. Was speaking to a supposed relative of a now departed player who ranted at me fr 15 mins about how the slug will sit filling his fat face with food while watching the players swim length after length in the pool etc, and that no-one has any respect for him. Also looks like he's coachign ability out of players, just playing boring rugby.

Who should we get in? Dont think it matters, anyone with a bit of passion whos more interested in the club than they are in fluffing scouse eddie would be an imporoement.

I think widnes will with the great sponsorship from stobarts and ste o connor.We had the biggest average attendances in the championship than salford.We have had longer in the championship than salford so interest is bound to go.In 2005 sl widnes averaged 6700 and that was a poor team.We deserve a chance as much as any other club such as salford,celtic,wakey or castleford.Why should anyone be given the god given right.Think teams are lucky their is no relegation and promotion.

Red, amber and black 'til McRae gets the sack.

Your financial record has earned you a three year stint in the Championship.

If it wasn't for SoC you could be Swinton by now.

Perhaps you should concentrate on trying to do well down there rather than taking cheap shots at SL clubs who are going through tough times?

Ha ha was thinking something similar myself

OK, I've allowed my disappointment to fade a little and here are my thoughts.

Alker should be in 2nd row and absolutely nowhere near the dummy half, I can pick up the ball quicker than him. On friday the defesive line was on the receiver before he got the ball.

Put one of the Smiths at Hooker.

we need some tactics and McRae if you don't know what the issue/problem is do the decent thing and resign.

We need to sort out the centre position, McGillvary was left with no protection on friday which resulted in 3 tries.

Well played to Holdsworth the stand out player and only one who looked lively.

I've had several bosses in my time who have hardly been inspirational to me, but that has never stopped me doing my job to the best of my abilities becasue I have personal pride in what I do. Pity some of the players don't seem have that same personal pride.

I haven’t read every post so apologies if repeating what others have said. Friday’s performance was absolutely woeful, our players were totally out muscled and enthused by a team that wanted it so much more than our guys from 1 to 17. Yes OK we had a couple of outside backs missing and lost Cashmere with an injury early but we couldn’t even make a fight of it. With the exception of Holdsworth who made a few clean breaks the team just looked like a bunch of amateurs and completely out of their depth.

I just can’t understand why McRae or Simms didn’t react to the tactical high kicks to the left after the first couple of tries conceded. To ignore it and do nothing and then allow it to happen another three times is one of the poorest coaching decisions I’ve ever witnessed. Why didn’t they take off ‘little McGillivray’ and switch Sibbit (6’3) to centre and Gibson to the wing??

The team sadly lacked enthusiasm and creativity and this game must go down as one of the worst Salford home performances I’ve ever witnessed, and I’ve seen some shockers over the years.

For the first home fixture you would think the Coaches and players would be so fired up to get the fans behind them? But it seems they are totally clueless to the commercial impact that kind of performance will have on the club.

Very tempted to make that post my new sig.

If I knew for a fact that tha majority of Reds players read this board regularly I definitely would.

I too was bitterly dissapointed on Friday night.I looked at the size of our team against the size of Crusaders and thought straight away we were going to be in trouble.I agree, why on earth after the first try in the opening minutes did the alarm bells not start ringing. To concede one try to the bomb into the corner was bad , two was terrible, but five is criminal . It was painful to watch it coming [ if we could see the bomb coming, why didnt the coach I have seen no progress what so ever under SM in two and a half years.
Is it his coaching , or is it the players he is working with ?
All the other teams will now spot this weakness and try to exploit it, you can bet on it.
You need somebody who can at least jump to try and diffuse these bombs.

Just to let people know.

I looked at the weight of a few other packs in super league and if the super league website is correct we actually have one of the heaviest in Super League!!!!!

Think somebody else hit the nail on the head pointing out we didn't come up in a line at all and we didn't hit the ball at pace until LULU and Boyle came on.

I have yet to see our new pack in action - not long though until the Harlequins game. However, it's not just about weight. It's also about presence and what you do with it.

Correct. Also, an 18 stone fat lad is always going to lose against a 16.5 stone muscle bound athlete.
Furthemore, don't be fooled by the stats. There's about a hundred reasons why the could be wrong. Far from scientific.