yeah mate, really not impressed. He has never one stood out for me, lack pace and agression, and seems to have his head up his ar$e a lot of the time. And thanks to Mr Mcrae we got him on a 3yr contract, genius!!

When Adamson first broke in to the team I recall him being moved to the centre due to injuries and he looked very promising in attack. I also recall an excellent try he scored from distance against Huddersfield at the Galpharm.

The question is why when he was showing so much promise has he not developed that early potential? I can only put this down to the coaching tactics of McRae by implementing a safety first ‘damage limitation’ game plan. It seems he (and others) was discouraged from playing anything other than a percentage game where having a real go and making the odd handling error or stray pass was considered criminal. The point is, how can any player improve his attacking skills when he’s been instructed not to try things and learn from his mistakes in a match situation?

If you look at the top sides in Superleague they often play ‘off the cuff’ rugby and often make errors but they seem to counteract these errors with solid defence, winning the collision, territory battle and having a better kicking game. The problem with the percentage game is it relies on getting everything right and once you fall behind you aren’t asking enough questions of the opposition in defence.

Reflecting back on a few occasions where Salford has played a more cavalier style has resulted in some memorable and highly entertaining wins against Saints a couple of times at the Willows over recent years and Hull KR and Bradford last year.

Let’s hope under PV he realises that Salford are in the entertainment business unlike McRae who feared the opposition and the potential damage to his own personal reputation. If we have a real go and fall short or get the odd hiding but entertain so be it. If we are going to lose I'd rather lose 52-32 than 12-4 in a dull game.

No more cautious 'percentage game' tactics please!

Well said, and that's what any genuine supporter is able to gather from supporting Salford.

This is exactly the sort of post that DI should be looking to emulate, although I dont see how thats going to be possible when he isnt going to be there to support them :/

Exactly, In the earlier games you saw a much improved Feka, my point being we saw a much improved Adamson against Wigan, WHICH YOU DIDNT WITNESS? What's hard to grasp about that, What you also choose to ignore is the fact Parish told Feka to find another club, which blows a hole in your theory...as Feka has improved...as has Adamson..keeping up?

I’m lucky to have attended all games bar Catalans since 2006 and have paid extra attention to Adamson because of the continuous effort and commitment he shows on the field, which has to be admired given how demoralising it must be at times. There’s no doubt he hasn’t progressed as fast as we would have hoped, but as mentioned above, that without doubt can be blamed on the lack of coaching and man management that occurred while SM was in charge. The raw abundance of talent, pace, and impact Adamson showed in 2006 & 2007 was a breath of fresh air and it’s that we saw glimpses of against Wigan. Not forgetting that this lad was picked up from Wigan’s academy by Salford while at the same time representing England which say’s something.

The fact is DI your opinion counts for diddly squat. Why? Firstly because you didn’t witness the much improved Adamson against Wigan, Secondly because you have openly admitted you don’t support Salford. The very definition of support means to be actively interested in, endure, tolerate, and encourage a team… You do none. You keep going while all and sundry continue to point out your flawed abusive unconstructive arguments. You may as well support Warrington for all the support you have and garbage you post. And that’s my point you’re not a Salford supporter, all your post’s focus around the unwitting T-W-A-T-S comment which again is pointless rubbish because your posting on a SUPPORTES forum. No one cares because unlike you deep down THEY WILL be attending the New Salford City Stadium to SUPPORT there team on the field. It’s the age old saying DI, if you’ve got nothing nice to say, don’t say owt.

And before you point out I’m wearing rose tinted glasses, please understand, yes I am, because I choose to. And before you point out you’ve been a supporter since 1932 but now you’ve given up, please understand I’m not up JW’s ar$e. Understand I support SCR’s. No one cares about your opinion, and It’s now the club and players need SUPPORT, Not your tirade of abuse. And since your not going to be attending any more games or supporting the club wouldn’t it be better to take something else up, a little less stressful for you perhaps ? Long walk’s? a bit of exercise perhaps? Just a thought.
.
I’m sure you’ll have invalid answers to all my valid points, and I’m sure you’ll be here every week criticising every performance, even though you won’t be attending. I for one am glad, as the club doesn’t need people like you.

Can't believe KMT re Nero, His defence is very good IMO. Has the experience and know how in attack and is reasonably pacey

Firstly you can't blame Mcrae for Adamson's form.The 2 prospects in Myler and Ratchford did quite well under him.....again corrected


You really do need a reality check. You're from St helens, you class yourself as a fan since 2006 the year Adamson joined. You're a relative hence your bias.....Your argument is flawed. It goes to show how sad you really are coming onto a Salford Forum trying to BIG up Adamson's game, trying to manipulate the supporters real opinions of the player because really the jury's out bigtime on your relative.how sad is that, Ha Ha Ha you saddo i bet you were a pie-eater when he was their, if he was transfered tomorrow you wouldn't be supporting Salford. Call yourself a fan ( absolute drivel ) i'm a fan but see the light my friend, i want the best for salford, that means a total clear out which includes your relative.........SADDO

Could'nt agree more Adamson so obviously was told up the jumper and head down by SM. For me before this he had the makings of a future England second row and was going places, post he's stagnated and seems to have lost his way.
I'd venture to say that if he moved to a top six team he'd soon revert to that origional player with promise, what I'm hoping is that he will be given the chance to do that this year under Vauxhall.

Utter b0llocks by the man in the supposed know yet again.
Ratchford went backwards under McRae and the same for Myler.
Both left, one for money and the other due to the fact he he was often dropped for no reason and played out of position.
It would appear you have a liking for McRae and his tactics, if so please fook off to Hull and support them.

As for the rest of your post, pathetic and infantile comes to mind.

Personally Nero since he has arrived he has been a big positive for me, good defender, busy in attack always wins the collision and has the quickest play of the ball at the club for us to play off.
Will be a big year for him to see if he can keep up that standard.

Well maybe I am missing it when I watch him then but I have not been that impressed at all with him. I haven't seen this pace that your on about or this lightning play the ball.When he plays second row he doesn't offer enough agression and when he plays centre I can't recall the last time he gave his winger any service at all Fair enough he is defencivly sound but thats not enough for me, I just don't think he is a very intelligent player. Maybe I expected too much of him when we signed him, as with quite a few of ths ignings last year.
Unlike DI I will continue to support him and cheer him on when he wears the shirt,but I do want more!!

DI how can say Ratchford did well under McRae? It was obvious that McRae didn’t even rate him. This is why he was often left out of the side or was used mainly for cover as a utility player. Centre, Wing, Fullback, Hooker, anywhere but his best position in the halves.

Prior to Ratchford signing from our academy he had future International written all over him but his progression was hampered by McRae and the player became increasingly disillusioned and frustrated. Unfortunately Tony Smith could see the potential and Ratchford could not resist the opportunity of jumping on the Warrington bandwagon.

As for Myler what part of his game would you say McRae improved? His creativity?.. His kicking game?..His defence? I’d say none. Myler has pace and a natural talent for backing up and being in the right place but he had this talent before he joined Salford. (This wasn’t coached into him)

Read it and weep DI - yet again, SOMEONE ELSE blowing your theory to bit's with the TRUTH - You have a bad habit of putting a vile twist on everything, which also makes you look like even less of a genuine (EX!) supporter. I'm still waiting for a response as to why your on here taking an interest when your not actually a supporter of the club?
If you've seen the light why are you on here making comments about players & staff at the club?

You need to absorb things when you read them, where did I say I started supporting the club in 2006? I said I am lucky to have attended every game since 2006 when Adamson arrived hence my interest in him..bit of a difference, prior to that I wasnt able to make it to every game due to family commitments.

You want the best for Salford yet your not attending anymore games and you dont support the current setup? - Cant wait to see you answer that one!

I'll say it again - The very definition of support means to be actively interested in, endure, tolerate, and encourage a team… You do none. Explain then why your here on a supporters forum again?

Forget my "flawed" argument. Lets look at yours. You didnt witness the game against Wigan yet you come on here straight after the game mocking the performance? Then mocking Adamson after I stated he showed a massive improvement in that game? Just remind me how that's possible when you didnt witness the game ? and not really the sign's of a Salford Supporter are they. Which as I've said, your not.

Please answer each one of those questions directly rather than insulting me or anyone else in hope of creating a smoke screen.

Oh look DI...another one!

Answers please....not insults & smoke screens or infactual "drivel"

I have a feeling every ones favourite GM Chimp will be spouting-off on here on Saturday evening/Sunday after witnessing the game on the box. That's if we lose. If we win, you might not see him for another week. Either way, it wont be long until his keyboard diarrhoea comes back with a blast.

I cant believe the s*** people talk on here how can you say adamson deserves a starting place yeah his defence is good but bring him off the bench. sidlow is a massive waste of dung .. how people can slag boyle of is another joke.for me as well wild isn't a 13 just another second rower in my opinion. my team for cas is
Patten
Broughton
Gleeson
Moon
Williams
DJ
Smith
James
Godwin
Boyle
Ashurst/Mcpherson due to both having slight injuries
Wild
Anderson

Gledhill
Feka
Howarth
Adamson/nero

Whatch you talkin' 'bout willis?

Personally I feel Adamson will have to improve his attacking game this year to deserve a starting place. I see him behind McPherson, Ashurst, Anderson, and on a par with Sidlow. I think Adamson is more valuable to Salford in the absence of Wild due to his work rate in defence.

adamson was in bar & grill in trafford yesterday, he had a right good dung in the bogz when i was in, must of lost about 10 stone, he'll be faster than broughton and playing the wing saturday. you heard it here first chaps.

HA HA HA
HE HE HE
S A L F O R D
& WHEN I KISSED HER ON DA LIPZ
I CUD TASTE DA FISH N CHIPS
HA HA HA
HE HE HE
S A L F O R D

oh dear

the zoo has a new occupant

Whatch you talkin' 'bout willis?





Theres always one int there !!!!!

Sidlow needs to go for me hes so bad for his size Wild for second row vinnie for loose

19 man squad: Salford: Patten, Broughton, Moon, Gleeson, Williams, Holdsworth, Smith, Jewitt, Godwin, James, Ashurst, McPherson, Wild, Nero, Adamson, Anderson, Howarth, Paleaaesina, Gledhill. No Boyle, Sidlow, Gibson, Neal, Vievers or Sneyd. Castleford:Owen, Arundel, Dixon, Griffin, Chase, Orr, Emmitt, Clark, Ferres, Walker, Jones, Milner, Hudson, Mitchell, Holmes, Massey, McGoldrick, Nash, Davies. superleague.co.uk/preview/7450

19 man squad: Salford: Patten, Broughton, Moon, Gleeson, Williams, Holdsworth, Smith, Jewitt, Godwin, James, Ashurst, McPherson, Wild, Nero, Adamson, Anderson, Howarth, Paleaaesina, Gledhill. No Boyle, Sidlow, Gibson, Neal, Vievers or Sneyd. Castleford:Owen, Arundel, Dixon, Griffin, Chase, Orr, Emmitt, Clark, Ferres, Walker, Jones, Milner, Hudson, Mitchell, Holmes, Massey, McGoldrick, Nash, Davies. superleague.co.uk/preview/7450

I dont care what team plays against cas, as long as there is 100% effort from every player thats all i ask,,

As for DI i dont know why u let him get to u lot, just ignore him, dont reply to his posts,and sooner or later the pratt will go away.

Or even better, if the mods cud just put every post he makes into his own post , marked WHAT RUBBISH I TALK, that wud be even better,

cant make sat stuck in norwich with work, the delights of being a coach driver, but will be watching on sky,

good luck lads,

[urlhttp://viewtopic.php?f=20&t=517627&start=10[/url
I know DI seems to get on everyones wick , but he called Boyle's ommission which I guess is the major surprise.

I think if you make him a foe (go into his profile and it's on there somewhere) you'll never see his posts again.

It's come as no surprise to me after watching the first two friendlies. Boyle should have been tearing it up against National League opposition, this for me is why he was left out for the Wigan match. How could PV leave Gledhill out now after a decent performance against the pies?

Let's hope this is a wake up call and he comes back more determined and finds a bit extra. I'd imagine missing the Cas game will hurt Boyle with it being his former club.