This particular song is fine, however I cannot comprehend how any of those young kids can sing it when we are still behind on the scoreboard?



'IF' we go ahead 'AND' the games sown up then yes sing it! 'DO NOT' sing it on ANY other occassion FFS



It's an unwritten rule that some still need to learn!

Fair enough. I'd agree with that.

Bit unfair i think, most of those chants have been being sung for as long as ive been watching salford. Nowt wrong with a bit of barracking the opposition, like we did with Mason at Hull kR. Not sure what people want, applaud the opposition on to the pitch? Need to make it a horrible place to come for whoever were playing.
Agree with what you say about timing though, its all about the timing

The content, whilst rather tired out and in need of a dose of satire in my humble opinion, isn't my major concern. For me, it's all about...............................................timing.

As for applauding the opposition team off the pitch. Hmm. It's become pretty trendy at our place. Whilst on occasion it's appropriate, e.g., when we've watched the opponents produce a brilliant display, or when we've watched a much smaller and weaker team have a really good go without lowering the tone of the game.

Spot on mate - every single word.

Maybe we should get someone holding up auto cue cards in the shed so people will know what to sing and when?
This will save all this moaning. Surely the idea is to be spontaneous not sound like we are in a television studio with canned laughter etc.

It never used to matter what was sang or when we sang it, whether we were winning or losing we used to have fun mixed with a certain amount of irony an sarcasm.

To be perfectly honest I am the perfect supporter. Everyone else shouldn't even bother turning up. You all embarrass me!!!

C'mon, after the Hull KR game there was a designated thread for how good the atmosphere, particulary in The Shed, was. Lets face it, the attendance was low and the game was terrible. The atmostphere was never going to be great. Lets just get back to how it was v Hull KR

you could have started any song in France and lloret and everyone would have joined in. That's how good the atmosphere was before during and after the game. Wish the same could be said about castleford on Sunday, but we'll have a go. No jaigermeister though Ave it.

do you want them pictures from the toilets in the Weavers the other Saturday night

Just because you can afford or not afford to go to Catalan doesn't make you a good or bad supporter.


Next you'll be saying that only real supporters go home and away games

I don't accept when people use going to Catalan as proof of Top Redness but surely following the team home and away is a pretty important aspect of being a supporter?

Maybe for those who have no commitments. But the fact that someone can go to every home and away game doesn't make them a better or more loyal supporter than someone like myself who due to work/finance commitments cannot go to every game.

Red John step forward



sorry about the Cas match

Worst thread ever

Thanks for your contribution

You disagree?

It's thoroughly depressing to see fellow Reds at each other's throats like this.

It was better than yours

I wouldn't worry fungus is probably checking for a pulse

I agree with you on that one, but some things I had to get of my chest with some fans constantly on here thinking they can do no wrong and looking down at other fans as though they are scum. Anyway ill end it there were all Salford fans and need to try and all get along a little better, if the atmosphere is ever going to get good again.

Whilst I agree with the principle of the second sentence, I feel that the first perhaps represents a kind of 'false status consciousness' within some sectors of the support. The old "that lot think they're better than me/us" attitude. I can't speak for others but in my opinion, for what it's worth, I don't think I'm better than anyone else; I just don't share many aspects of the same culture. Not better, but different. However, if we could focus on the similarities we'd perhaps get somewhere. But, this requires the aforementioned to contribute rather than thinking others look down their noses at them. And, don't expect others to simply join in with behaviour they don't wish to. I.e., singing pointless songs (in my opinion) at inappropriate times. (IMO)

I don't expect anyone to join in songs/chants they don't wish to because i will admit myself half the time i dont join in with them because at times they make me cringe but at the same time if the same group of people start a Salford song of there's a select few that wont join in which in my opinion is childish. The thing is there is obviously a divided in our support and has been for a few seasons i want to go to the games to enjoy the experience not listen to fellow reds fans argue with each other, my original post wasn't to try and have a pop at people but i feel the group who start these songs of get a lot on unwarranted stick and whilst the songs may not be the best at times i don't feel there's any need to take it any further and let it bother people to much and come on here and post about them. We don't have to all see eye to eye and be best pals with each other, i just want all this bitching to stop and start to enjoy the last season at the famous old ground to give it the send of it deserves.

Well said Darren



thats what we all should be wanting this season.

oohh aahh lloret der mar

He know's he is