Looks out of shape and a bit of a pudding so far. Castleford have kept putting him under the high ball and he seems too big and immobile to jump. Reminds me very much of Francis Meli so far.

Hahaha, I know its his first game back but I can see exactly what you mean.

Early days IMO. Big unit could well.be devastating when fit

The question is why isn't he fit? He's had ample time to keep his heart rate levels above par.

Seriously? Sums you up and why people don't like your comments

It's common knowledge his first game back was meant to be magic weekend, he's back 2 games early to help our the team. Yet you come out with this tripe.

Get over yourself.

He was no great shakes today, granted, but he by now means was the worst, and I know better is to come

I'm gutted about today, but the last person I'm looking at is vidot

A spade is a spade, I don't give two Tom Tits what you lot think. If you want the diluted drivel you know where to go. And I ain't blaming Vidiot for the defeat, I just stated an observation that he's nowhere near fit enough to play at this standard. Denny Solomona had him in his pocket all afternoon.

The pack is nothing but spineless, and I'm sick of the same old cliches being tooted by the management. "Hopefully, we'll bounce back next week bollix''.

Devils, Gee whiz this shower of Tom Tit are a mere Cats compared to the warriors what got this club it's prestigious nickname.

U2 Mario and FLAT need to p11s of this web site untill u can finding something good to say END OFF.

I am fine with negative comments or constructive criticism where it's due, and jeez its due today, but to blame vidot is spineless. For the reasons I've already mentioned.

To blindly back your mate against me making my opinion is just daft.

I'm gutted about today. More than I have been for many years. I understand people booting off in anger. But vidot should not be the aim.

Vidots debut wasn't all it was made up to be but it is his first competitive game in about 6 months.

We definately missed a recognised 9 today and a pack leader, the pack go dominated.

Take my hat off to Powell with 6 first teamers missing they still did a very good job on us.

Careful. You'll be leading the clique if you're not careful.

No you didn't. Mario did

Gadger, Take a chill pill. you're twisting my words.

Oh Diddums, If there was anything positive to vent about Salford, I'd be the first to acknowledge the crux of the matter,If you can't handle the truth, and need a more of a diluted analysis, you know where to go.

Who the hell are you to patronize my allegiance to Salford. I've been watching for 38 years,I'm born and Bred Salford. I should be patronizing you about deserting your beloved Salford.to go living in the interbreeding capital of Britain? The Butcher very rarely attends, he's never lived in Salford, not even from Salford. If you're questioning allegiances I should be last on your list.

Hahahaha, Strange fellow, you need a more diluted site badly.[u END OFF[/u

Don't need a pill but I am now more chilled

I wasn't twisting your words, itp was aimed at marios comments

I've not seen vidot play enough to say he's going to be a world beater, but I certainly won't be judging him on that performance

Whatever. With regards to Vidot, I'll give him a few weeks to improve his fitness. But what worries me especially with him being a three-quarter, is even when a decent player is unfit or returning from a lengthy layoff they often still somehow show glimpses or flashes of skill and evasiveness to which I struggled to observe with Vidot. Yes, it's his first game and I wasn't expecting him to pull up trees, but showing Zero potential and Zero flashes of any evasive footwork or the lack of any glimpses of his well-known reputation worry me. if he turns out to be another Justin Carney well I'll hold my hands up, but my intuition guides my adjudication towards another Junior Langi in disguise. Hope I'm wrong Gadger.

Occam's razor: he's not yet fit.
As you know from your decades of RL, there is a difference between fit and match fit. He's not at the second level yet.

I've an end-of-year appraisal coming up. Are either of you two available to ghost write it? Then the negatives could be listed and I could cast aroung for any positives from elsewhere?

It's a team game.... some people seem to have missed that and continue to find fault and blame with individual players / officials / RFL.

It never seems to be our fault as a team or the fact that the 'team' were not good enough over 80 minutes.

Too many people who watch this game simply don't understand it.

I liked the interview in the MEN today and I for one jumped on the bandwagon with regards to his performance. I was expecting him to add an x factor but the guy needs games. I don't think we will see the best of him till the bottom 8. But I expect his partnership with Jones to grow. We need to get back on the wagon and climb the league. The draw made me feel better as I wouldn't fancy playing Wigan next and now we have a weak cough.

Bring on the saints!!!

My query is why did he drop Evalds who seemed to be doing a decent job and scoring tries.Surely Vidot should have been coming off the bench.I think there seems to be a bit of an agenda with Niall and the coaching staff at the moment,whatever the rights and wrongs.

Just me who thought it was a decent performance for his first game of RL in 9 months? I thought he returned the ball well and his defending to prevent Solomona scoring that try (which ended up being awarded) was excellent. Yes he was out jumped by Solomona earlier in the game but he isn't the first winger and wont be the last either.

Another 80 minutes on Friday will do him the world of good.

I thought his performance was okay as well. Not bad considering he's not played for 9 months and come back a bit early. Didn't set the world alight but didn't do much wrong either in a game that was fairly lacking on the performance meter from nearly everyone.

Thought he was great yesterday. Do any of the doubters agree?

I'm not a doubter, I also thought he had a good game yesterday. like Carney he took the ball up and helped the forwards out. He needs at least 6 to 8 games to get his touch/timings right, I think he will come good. We will need a good centre when we lose one of our backs to Saints next season

Who's off now?

I think some folk is actually jumping the gun a bit with Vidot just for scoring Two walk-ins that even my old mate the butcher would have scored. He was nothing special going forward , however, he was frequently enthused to take the ball up. Which is a Non-negotiable. job to do.

But, as Wingers go he looks unorthodox, he's gait looks slow and flat footed, I think if he had a clear running chance, he'd be caught within seconds. The jury is still out for me until he gets fit, but Winger's shouldn't, as a rule, take ample time for this to improve however looking at Vidot his fitness levels don't look any better than Two weeks ago at Castleford. We'll have to wait and see but bigging him up for Two walk-ins is setting him up to fail and very short sighted.