If we did get rid of mcrae who would you like to see get the job i would love to see john pendlebury given a chance

stuart raper

pengy

Matt Calland

I jut want a winner? It would make a nice change!

paul kidd,he's not flavour of the month at swinton so he maybe looking to move onto pastures new!!

There's your answer folks.

john kear deffo

alan hunte look what he has done to the academy

Holly Willoughby i wouldnt careless about results

Holly Willoughby!!! she has her knockers but i like her!!! (its ok im wearing me coat!!)

There are lots of people I'd prefer as coach, but I can think of a couple of reasons to appoint Holly Willoughby?!

McRae has to go - He misses too many tackles, knocks on too much and gives too many penalties away. And don't even get me started on the lack of tries he scores...

didnt karl harrison get sacked for less than what mcrea's done?

I'd get rid of mcrae, doesnt seem 2 motivate them at all I can think of 3 coaches I'd like in charge. John Cartwright, Karl Harrison, Ian Millward. They are all good motivators which mcrae certainly isnt

I don't think getting rid of our head coach at this stage of the season will prove anything.

We all expected a rough ride this season if we are honest, but of course yesterdays woeful performance at the HJ Stadium was totally unaceptable and a repeat will see more than the coach getting shown the door for sure.

There is only a few games left now this season and I would like to see a few of our younger players given a chance in the first team, the likes of Lewis Palfrey and Marlon Alker should be breaking through in 2010 and I feel in the last few games this season it would do them no harm to get a taste of what in store for them in the future.

Wayne Bennett with Craig Bellamy as his assistant.

If motivation is the problem, it's wierd how he can motivate them for the first half but not the second?!

Getting rid of our coach at this point would be a waste of time and money. If he wanted to quit I wouldn't shed any tears, but there's no way I'd want the club to be spending money on paying off his contract.

The fact that he has managed to put build, coach and motivate a team who can beat Leeds, Saints, Hudds and Wire is enough to convince me that there are reasons to be optimistic.

The challenge for next season is to keep those occasional, impressive victories but to ensure consistency between them.

And besides, I can't think of one coach who would be a significant improvement on McRea who would be interested in coaching Salford at present.

Wayne Bennett
Brian Smith
Kevin Moore
John Cartwright

well you weren't being serious so why should I be?

Good Post.

I agree.

I feel that the players are more to blame at the moment than McRae. They have shown that they can beat the best when they play to their potential, so results like yesterday are a hard pill to swallow. There was no real tactical reason to lay the blame on our coach for shipping the ridiculous amount of points that they did. A coach can only do so much, and the players really need to ask themselves some questions.

Of course, there are lots of external factors that may come into play but at the end of day, the Club needs to sit down and look at what we can do to sort this out. I thought the dark days of shipping half a century of points and more were well behind us.

I just hope we are not slipping back into those times, and the end of the season can't come quick enough...

the names suggested kinda prove why we shouldnt be changing our coach...

Oh, I know, perform a miraculous ressurection and get Lance Todd running the show again...

The same thing happened at Cas.
Difference there was that the replacements they brought in were quality as they can afford to do this on the crowds they get.
We no doubt will bring in second rate Aussies, past it players who have nowhere else to go and therefore will end up 13th or even bottom.
I have said it time and time again a winning team brings in crowds.
Next year for me is $hit or bust for Salford.
We need to get quality in to get up the league and show we are a improving team,yes I know you will say but we have no money but just for once we need to show we nean business.
That and the new stadium (hopefully will commence next year)will give us a new franchise.
Stay as we are and NL beckons

I agree with that. he had a shocker yesterday as well