Smokey TA has decided he doesnt like Brough an no amount of actual evidence will prove otherwise, clearly he forgets Brought serious injury last season meant he missed the Exiles game and struggled to get his form back

Currently he is the best scrum half in the country, and has matured into that beyond all recognition from his former self at other clubs

What evidence?, lets look at the clubs he's played for throughout his career.. York, Wakefield, Hull, Castleford and now Huddersfield.
Yep, it's conclusive, he's the player all the top clubs want. I don't believe he's any different now to before he joined Huddersfield.

1. Tomkins

2. Charnley
3. Watkins
4. Reed/Atkins
5. Hall

6. Widdop
7. Brough

8. Graham
9. Roby
10. Burgess
11. Westwood
12. Ellis
13. O'Loughin

14. Hock
15. Morley
16. Robinson
17. Mossop

Thats a pretty strong team.

Infact Id have Henderson as the interchange hooker.

On current form

Tomkins
Hall
Atkins
Watkins
George

Widdop (give him more than 5 mins)
Brough

Peacock
Roby
S burgess
Ellis
Westwood
O'loughlin

Morley
Hock
Graham
Burrow

I'm finding it quite heart warming to finally see some competition for the outside back positions given that a few years ago it was Old Mother Hubbard.

Have people forgot Jack reed???

Well one clown thinks Leroy Cudjoe is a better player

So basically this topic is asking for peoples INDIVIDUAL possible selections based on form but when offered their view its shot down because there is 'no chance' that a said player will get in the team ???

Why bother asking then lol i wasnt saying George should be in the England squad ahead of Charnley or anyone else i was merely saying that if it WAS picked on form then he is IN EXCELLENT FORM and hypothetically would be in a FORM side !!!

In other words, pick a team that you think will be the nearest to the actual one picked rather than a team on CURRENT FORM

this

isnt this team supposed to be on current form?.. isnt george the top try scorer?. then he should be in the current form team of everybody.or is this just another england team debate

If its on current form, hasn't Roby been injured for weeks?

i didnt forget jack reed. i have seen him in a couple of games this year and he is not in his best form. the title is on current form and i believe he isnt the best centre on current form.

Sam Tomkins

Ryan Hall
Kallum Watkins
Jack Reed
Josh Charnley

Gareth Widdop
Jonny Lomax

James Graham
James Roby
Sam Burgess

Gareth Ellis
Danny Tickle
Sean O'Loughlin

Andy Lynch
Eorl Crabtree
Jon Wilkin
JJB/Sinfield

7 is difficult as Chase is a kiwi, Brough has changed between England an Scotland more than I have changed my underpants and don't agree with that. Would say Lomax is best young English 7 an deserves a chance.

On form at moment would have to include Tickle and Lynch as both have been impressive, and wouldnt pick Morley or Peacock as both are getting too old and form wise there are better forwards at the moment IMO

Tomkins
Hall
Reed
Watkins
Charnley/BJB
Widdop
Brough
Burgess
Roby
Graham
Ellis
Westwood
O'Loughlin

Hock
Patrick
Mossop
Burrow

Would definately have a backline of:
Tomkins
Charnley
Watkins
Reed
Hall

not too certain about the halves yet, would have Brough at 7 so far. Burrow on the bench is a must as well.

Based on what I've seen this is the "form team," not to be confused with the team I would pick if England were playing next week.

Tomkins
George
Cudjoe
Watkins
Charnley
Mcguire
Brough
Lynch
Houghton
Graham
Tickle
Westwood
Sinfield

No room for Atkins then ?

Make room for Scott Taylor soon, the guy is sensational

Fully agree Scott Taylor's progression is massive. By the end of the season he'll have forced his way into the full squad.

Quite a few actually.

I think Danny Kirmond may push for a place against the Exiles, might not be in a top four team but still playing immensely - defense and attack wise.

1. Tomkins
2. Hall
3. Atkins
4. Reed
5. Briscoe
6. Brown
7. Brough
8. Peacock
9. Roby
10. Graham
11. Ellis
12.
13. Burgess

14. Burrow
15. Taylor
16. Morley
17.

Not sure who would fill in as second row (Manu if he's still eligible) or as the fifth benchman.

Admittedly I'm not his greatest fan, but Reed deserves to keep his place after last year. He also built a good partnership with Hall and I think he has played at left centre for Brisbane. I also think Watkins is one of the most exciting attacking players in the league, he has everything you want from a centre, tonight obviously showed he has some positional issues but he will only learn playing (hopefully) a full season at centre.

On current form reed has had a couple of shocking games not looking at his best