Last year's top tackler who has been even better this season apart from a bad shoulder injury that kept him out of the team is overrated? Did you see his try away at Leeds this year? Absolute belter.

Last years top tackler was malcolm alker

My apologies, it was 2008. Im forgetting what year it is now.

There are some decent sides being put together filled with "overrated" players, I'd fancy some of those teams to finish in the top 4 or 5.

are these teams really over-rated or just players posters don't like!?

1 Jordan Tansey
2 Mark Calderwood
3 Michael Shenton
4 Kirk Yeaman
5 Ade Gardner
6 Scott Murrell
7 Paul Cooke
8 Nick Scruton
9 Scott Moore
10 Luke Burgess
11 Epalahame Lauaki
12 Graeme Horne
13 Joe Westerman

I think the inclusion of Cooke & Horne (G) in the post below answers that query.

Coming from somebody who claims a 4 times Grand Final winning captain is over-rated that's an interesting comment

2005 Cooke would not be nowhere near the 13, 2010 Cooke is however.

I also do not mind Graeme Horne, but I fail to see what he has ever contributed to a team?

You miss my point, neither of those players are exactly raved about by fans, or cause Eddie/Steve to have to change their undercrackers at half time, so its hard to see how they can be classed as over rated.

1. Paul Wellens
2. Will Sharp
3. Michael Shenton
4. Kieth Senior
5. Lee Smith
6. Paul Cooke
7. Richard Myler
8. Stuart Fielden
9. Mark Riddell
10. Nick Scruton
11. Harrison Hansen
12. Joel Tomkins
13. Shaun O'Loughlin

This thread is over

Leeds Rhino's

Now it can be closed

Lots of hate for young Myler!!!

Hasn't performed to a level near his hype and transfer fee IMO. Still been a good player, but not as good as the gruesome twosome and Warrington fans would have everyone else believe. I'm still of the belief that Salford kept the better of their 2 young half backs.