Hillsborough had nothing to do with the standard of the stadium.

how about the point about the fact that with the absence of relegation the interest in lower table activity of super league is greatly compromised skinhead?

And what part of the argument as been flawed?

Let me ask you a simple question for such a educated guy.

If Quinns....crowds keep falling....thier performance fall...they stop selling merchendise...etc etc...do you really think RFL will relagate them?

not if wellesy has her way. shed rather these teams be given chance after chance on the grounds of mental illness

Is this a sport forum ?

Hey, it's the Bugster. Howdy. Let's talk sport. What happened tonight?

Usual different day whats new ?

Is it?

What about when Halifax got relegated with about 10 weeks to go? How interesting was the bottom of the table then?

Or when Widnes AND Leigh were down with about 5 weeks to go?

Relegation does not guarantee interest at the bottom of the table for the full season. Conversely, it doesn't guarantee that their won't be any interest at the bottom all season, as they could still get into the play-offs.

So yeah, again flawed argument.

Not this thread

The RFL wouldn't need to. They'd probably go bust.

The fact is, they meet the criteria in a lot of areas and are deserving of their franchise.

well.....? this is my part of the argument.

Do you think RFL will relagate them...I think NOT...

Rules are made to be broken...just ask the RFL

If a club does all of that they will get a license. It was said by Nigel Wood that the best performing NL club will get a license.

Congratulations for bringing out 3 examples from the history of super league which argue otherwise. clearly my argument is outgunned by such strong counter evidence. The wakefield/castleford battle, thinking about it, was a complete waste of interest.

For God's sake STOP throwing this back into these arguments. I don't want to read it. It was 6 years ago. SIX ! Let it go.




bluesox4evaaa - shut the f**k up ! You're forcing people to drag up the horrid past of Halifax RLFC. You're also embarrassing yourself. Enough already. Enough.

Or your post

Losing interest rapidly , like lots of our fans

Are you really that desperate that you have to start acting sexist to make yourself feel superior? I know you're failing to bring up a decent argument, but I didn't think you needed to sink THAT low!

OMG ..o.k they stop meeting the critia in any fu***g shape or form then...stop trying to twist your argument

or lets just say halifax meet more critia points than Quinns/Wigan etc...would RFL swap them places ?

I am certainly not. in fact i am thoroughly enjoying this.

Sorry, I had no intention of bringing up a bad part of your history to embarrass you!

If your ansrew is no...then this is just not the way forward....if you answer yes...I think you lieing to yourself

If they would then yes...maybe this is the way forward, but in a realistic world of RFL thats not going to happen is it?

On or Off pitch , and who makes that decision ?

........... your lack of substance and basic grasp of reality is making your contributions embarrassing. It's a bit cringeworthy to be honest.

going with a womans argument on this issue would be more dangerous than allowing a monkey to fly a plane

I aren't trying to twist anything. You're trying to bring up a completely hypothetical argument that you cannot prove right or wrong, so no matter what I reply you will still disagree with. What's the point?

If Wigan, Saints or anyone in the SL didn't meet ANY criteria to be in SL, then I guarantee that they would not be in the SL. Anyone that is trying to argue that they would despite not meeting ANY criteria is simply idiotic.

It'll count against them in the next round of license applications.