Not really sure who's in form and isn't at the moment, but surely if it's on form alone and not reputation then a few Cas and Widnes players have to be in there.

from the Giants Lunt and Murphy are probably our best 2 at the moment.

I saw James Graham throwing the Canterbury scrum halfs name (Trent Hodgkinson) in the ring on the Sydney morning herald site. His father is English and is meant to be keen for him to turn out for England.

I don't know anything about him tbh. Any good?

He's probably better than Myler, Smith, Robinson etc.

He's playing well at the moment, but it's hard to tell if it's good form or class yet ...

Has it been officially confirmed the England V Exiles concept has been scrapped for good?

Or is the concept temporarily on hold?

He would be useless at 6 as he needs to work to the game plan at 6 and organise. At 1 he can chime in when he wants and cause havoc. Thats why Wigan, England and the NZ warriors play him at 1. Or do you know best??

Hypothetically speaking, if Tomkins and Billy Slater were both Welsh, would you only expect one of them to be picked in their starting line up.

Nah, they would have been picked by Gatlin and Edwards and playing Yawnion

he broke through at wigan as a half and played his junior rugby in that role so hardly an alien concept to him.there has been talk of him making the switch back to half back for the Warriors and if that happens at some point this season it is likely he will play in that role for England but even then it wont be as the team organisor as Widdop will get that task the way he is playing for St George.

Would be interesting to see how many games he played in the halves for Wigan. Just cos he played there when he was ypung doesnt mean thats his position. Jason Robinson was signed as a scrum half ?
Leave him at Full back he is one of the best in the world with No 1 on his back.