Leaving aside all the taking, Slater is a wonderful player and McClennan is an excellent coach.

mate seriously, hes won SL 2 or 3 times?

would he get an NRL head coach job.

nope.

Maybe he would, maybe he wouldn't. To try and state either possibility as a fact is ridiculous. Nathan Brown has had one decent season in SL and is already supposedly heading back to an an NRL job after he's done at Hudds. McClennan has done more than Brown so far ( with greater resources though obviously) so why wouldn't he have a shot in the NRL?

remind me again where did Murray, McRae, Elliot and Millward end up after SL?

Mate you don't break Australia's stranglehold on the game at international level like the Kiwis did under McClennan in 2005 without a good coach.

The insularity of the Australian game is the only reason he wouldn't get a go in the NRL.

And you know where I reside.

thanks for proving my point!

i dont rate him as a coach. he couldnt get the kiwis regularly beating australia.

but hes been a star in SL. horses for courses

What that Australian ex Sl coaches do get NRL jobs or that Australian coaches are generally e?

english JB.

nathan brown failed in the NRL.

and then went to SL and is the coach of the year.

ian millward won everything as a coach in SL, and only managed to get an assistant coaching job here.

shaun mcrae also won titles and managed to only win a single NRL game as coach

mclennan would probably get an assistant coaching job here if he applied given his SL titles

justin morgan did nothing as an NRL coach and is apparently one of the top coaches in SL.

mick potter was an assistant NRL coach and also is one of the top coaches in SL.

now mark mcuire has been headhunted from assistant coaching at melbourne storm (one of several assistant coaches) for the head coaching job at wigan.

Assistant NRL coach = SL coach

SL coach doesnt necessarily mean you can get a job as an assistant NRL coach

Somebody's telling you porkies mate.

he coaches the club that are the 2nd strongest in SL.

Edited

Quote ="Steve-O"Edited '" The Table don't lie www.superleague.co.uk/

Quote ="Steve-O"Edited '" The Table don't lie www.superleague.co.uk/

Quote ="Jonesy"The Table don't lie www.superleague.co.uk/ '" Bookmarked for next year..

Quote ="Jonesy"The Table don't lie www.superleague.co.uk/ '" Bookmarked for next year..

Hows Daniel Anderson doing over there?

daniel anderson had already proven himself in the NRL before going to SL.

FYI he coached the NZ Warriors in 2002 when they made the NRL grand final, in addition to a good record as coach of the NZ national team.

pleased to be of help.

Yet he didnt dominate SL with arguably the strongest squad in SL,

he was also beaten in a grand final by both Tony Smith and Brian Mclennan

how very very strange

yes as a leeds fan i expect you to argue that way

using reasoning, logic, and evidence?

you should try it some time, it makes much more sense than the Dally style of just repeating idiotic statements, untruths, and then quickly trying to change the subject when his idiocy has been shown up

a little like you're trying now

do you want to log in as Barry now? try and pretend there is another idiot as big as you out there?

apart from elliot (who still may)

sacked

Yes this is the way to prove we are better.

Call one of their best players some names that imply he is not very good, when in fact, if given British citizenship, would be one of all time greats.

I do wonder whether people on here are being ironic or simply delude themselves. Unfortunately I fear it is more often the latter.

Brian Smith, John Monie or Daniel Anderson ring any bells? And don't give me the "they were NRL coaches before going to SL" Bollox! You can't only include the ones that suit your argument...well not unless you're a pea-brained Ocker, in which case you can continue to spout she-ite and no one will be in the least bit surprised. I'm sure you're also aware and choosing to ignore the fact that McGuire was being head hunted for at least 2 current NRL head coaches jobs before accepting the Wigan post.

My great grand father could probably coach Leeds to the SL title.

And he's been dead since 1985