I think it's worked quite well for Toronto personally. Most of their fans have absolutely no idea about rugby league at all so they're not particularly bothered that they're playing Whitehaven instead of Wigan. They're just going for the spectacle at the minute, which I think works better with the team winning every week and scoring loads of points. The fact that their crowds have gone up slightly as the season has gone on shows that the people going don't really care that none of the games are much of a contest. The fans will start to appreciate the increased level of competition as they're exposed to the game more which will also coincide with their games becoming more competitive.

It would have been a disaster to just throw them straight into Super League and expect people from Toronto to turn up in numbers each week to watch a sport they know nothing about and their team to mostly lose quite comfortably.

Interesting that the two clubs with the highest attendance in League 1 are both expansion clubs.

Credit to Newcastle to average over double Hunslet, a team with a tremendous amount of history. Hosting magic weekend certainly looks to have boosted the profile of the game up there with some amateur clubs also thriving. Why move magic weekend elsewhere?

How much was Newcastle's inflated by Magic Weekend though?

i can't agree, i think people would be much more interested in actual contests. People may not be all that familiar with RL, but nor are they stupid. I think its obvious and most are well aware of the standard of competition that they are in.

I think you are working backwards from Toronto's success and putting it down to them being at a low standard. Lets be honest here, Toronto have played a total of 7 home games, how would fans have learnt about these walkovers to be attracted by them? Their success is entirely down to the effort in sales, marketing and PR that the club have made and it is important that we recognise that because it is failings in these areas that effect nearly all clubs, not that they arent putting 80pts on the opposition every week.

Newcastle have put some good work in, althugh I have a feeling their attendances are down a bit on 2016 - it takes a long time to trawl through the attendances but I'll work out 2016 at some point.

Excluding Toronto's home matches, the highest attendance of the season so far is 2,111 on the millenium magic weekend for Newcastle against York. Again though I believe that is down on the same fixture in 2016.

Next highest attendance (excluding Toronto's home matches again) was 1,524 for London Skolars vs Toronto - this was the latters first league match.

I expect York to beat both these attendances this weekend, and should end the season as 2nd highest average. Crowds have gone up 49% at York (by the end of the season,expect it to be a 70% increase), in part because of the new regime who have stabilised things, but also the entertaining rugby which I genuinely think mirrors the Cas style of play in 2014+2015, and also allowing all under 16s in for free - I don't know of any other clubs who do this?

Some of the averages though are pitiful. Hemel for example have had just 820 through the gates this season for their 7 matches....take away comp tickets (players partners, relatives etc) and away support and they are probably getting 75 paying home supporters a match. I think there is potential at Coventry and North Wales Crusaders to grow further so not all hope is lost just yet.

I wouldn't place too much stock in the stated attendances at that level. In my experience they are inflated even to the poor numbers they state, so you are likely just comparing who inflated theirs the most rather than actual attendances.

Keighley have been doing this for 3 years

Hats off to York City Knights who today humbled Toronto 26 16.

Wish I'd put a tenner on that.

2,602 there to see a well deserved York win. A fantastic achievement to say York had no pre season, and weren't even in the initial league 1 fixtures. This time last year they even had to postpone their first match of the super 8s due to off field problems.

Toronto will still get promotion and will deserve it and I am one of those who think they are good for the game, but it's good to go down in the history books as being the first league team to defeat them.

One last point - it shows what can be done if you rise to the challenge on and off the pitch, create a buzz about the fixture, promote the hell out of it then do the job on the pitch. Here's hoping Workkngton and Keighley can put in a similar effort and pack them in!

Amazing by York!!!! Probably Toronto's only loss this year I bet. Great achievement.

Call me a simpleton but I think a clear cut simple system is the way forward. It's hard enough getting new faces to understand the rules to the game let alone a complex structure. I work in a county that doesn't have a pro RL club and when I try to explain to them how we win competitions and the structure they find it very hard to understand at first viewing which probably eliminates any interest before they have given it a good go.

Whatever structures you go with it's going to need time to grow and to allow player pools to expand. Chopping and changing isn't the answer, put a structure in place and allow it to grow.

I would personally go with.

14 team Super League - 27 games each (home and away plus magic weekend) bottom two go down and top 4 compete in play offs. Make it compulsory that all teams have a reserve and academy set up. Stadium Capacity must be at least 8000.

14 team Championship - 27 games (home and away plus summer bash) Make it compulsory to have at least a U18s set up and a permanent home base/long lease with min capacity 5000. Top automatically goes up and 2 to 5 to compete in play offs for second promotion spot. Bottom place to be relegated.

12 team League 1 22 games (home and away) Top gets promoted. Make it compulsory to have a permanent base with at least 3000 capacity. Bottom gets relegated should winners from the North & South fit criteria.

Setup a League 1 North & South for any future teams who wish to enter the pro leagues max to 10 teams each. Winners of either League to play each other in a grand final to gain promotion to League 1.

This structure could be made better I am sure but the guidelines let clubs know what is expected to move up the ranks. It also allows clubs to grow naturally. Some clubs will rise and others will fall, but that is the point of sport. This super 8s stuff is all confusing for the neutrals IMO.

why not 3x14 I think there a couple of clubs waiting in the wings to join C1.