Haha. It's a good job the voting players who played against him didn't agree with you.
He was damn good that season and deserved it, just like any other winner in any other year.

In my club bias jerry McGillvray has been outstanding for Huddersfield, but as with most players who play for unfashionable clubs will be under the radar..a bit like millington.. Great shout he's a real class act!

Roy asotasi

Minichello for me !!! Ellis and Paea not doing too shabby either .
It will probably go to one the usual suspects tbh ...

Campese for us has been absolutely phenomenal behind what should be a beaten pack, seen the last of him this year though.
Not been impressed with Carney even when fit, if he didn't have the reputation I doubt he'd be mentioned.
Roby has been very good as has been Taia. As much as it pains me to say it, Ellis has looked very very good for Hull, no coincidence they were awful without him, gone really well with him back. Minicello is solid but makes too many mistakes and causes penalties, again its Ellis whos lifted his performances.

So you think a player from Hull who are scraping the foot of Superleague warrants Man Of Steel



Deluded

Taia
Walmsley
Cuthbertson
Roby
Burgees

All miles ahead of anyone from Hull FC

Like Castleford or Huddersfield?

On admittedly limited viewings, Cuthbertson at Leeds seems a good shout; great feet for a big lad, and a clever reader of the game.

Hard to see past Taia though - he's been on fire this season.

It'll go to peacock or sinfield.

I'd have to say Cuthbertson, every time I've seen him play he's been unstoppable. His ability to offload is second to none.

Easily the front runner for Man of Steel.

You forgot to turn the 'Leeds Default Mode' off

Kevin Locke, obviously...

...Oh you meant who's actually been on the pitch?

I'll be back in a bit.

Foot of super league ? We're 8th with shame in hand against wakey ( win that and we would be joint 6th as of now )

Mos should go to the best player not who's playing for the highest placed team

Who'd be you choice ?

The last 6 years the the award has gone to a player from
Huddersfield x2
Cas x2
Wigan x2 so like I say ... Usual suspects



Last ten years it's
Wigan x3
Saints x3
Cas n Giants 2 a piece ... According to wiki that is , I thought Sinfield had previously won it ??

So you claim you can't pick a player from a team scraping the bottom yet your 1st name is from a team 1 position above this bottom team. Explain....

Elliot Whitehead has been going well

Nope. No Leeds player has since Harris in 98.

Both retiring so will get votes.

MOS- Chris Hill (can't believe he's not got a mention yet, he's absolutely immense every minute he plays. he's got great feet and passes very well for a prop too. he isn't someone who just gets his head down and runs in hard, he's got a great skill set as well as being a real man of steel who never takes a backwards step)

Young player- Benjamin Garcia (this lad's gonna be a superstar imo)

Agree he's top class, always at least a 7/10 phenomenal consistency. I don't think you can look past Cuthbertson this season though he's been unbelievable and helped transform Leeds' style.

you need to understand Rimmels' hate for everything hull fc related

If anything showed you up as an irrational thinker, it's this post!



Giving a reason based on a team performance to not pick a player, then picking a player from a team on the same amount of points as the first choice! Classic hypocrisy!

Remind me where Castleford finished in 2011 when Rangi Chase was MOS?

Don't think I've ever seen Chris Hill give a performance as low as 7/10. How dare you suggest such a thing!

Influentially and statistically I don't think anyone gets close to cuthbertson. If he keeps it going till September he should win mos at a canter.