what was that Carney. I think that's the definition of a brain fart.

Roby's kicking has been good so far.

I'd love to know how Eddie thinks a ball that goes 5 meter backwards is a knock on.

Cas finally in but Saints will be gutted with that defence.

and again, that was a good try from Cas.

Interesting that Cas seem to be making more yards down the middle than Saints.

No need, Amor.

good try that from Saints a man down and on the first tackle.

Saints will take that. Thought Atelea Vea had a solid game, along with Makinson and Jones.

We looked very tired, hardly surprising given last week. A low ebb performance from us, seemed to want to do just enough to get by, and that seemed to be the case. A wins a win as they say.

Ref evened it up in the second half to say the least...

Gritty win by Saints after being hammered last week and only having 5 days rest against an energetic Cas side who have had a 2 week preperation for this game.
It was always going to be a patchy game from saints when you have one second row playing scrum half and another second row playing centre.
Cas had lots of errors in passing and catching the ball which cost them a couple of tries.

Personally feel Saints benefitted by having the extra game and this early in the season a 5 day turnaround isn't much of a deal compared to say later on in the season. Bearing in mind we're only two games in having a week off so early is going to blunt your match day fitness and Saints would have had a point to prove (I would have thought!)
Few iffy decisions but Cas haven't done anywhere near enough to be getting close to a win

Does anyone have the attendance figure for saints? Don't know if I'm just being thick but cant seem to find it anywhere.

Thought Cas were the better team for large parts of the game to be honest. I think they're fairly unlucky to have lost 3 from 3. People were quick to write them off when they lost Clark, Huby and Sneyd but they've still got talent in every position and a great coach in Powell. I reckon they'll turn Wigan over next week.

attendnce TBC at the moment, from the Saints match report.

I agree, they have done better than i expected regards how close they have got in the last 2 games, i guess they will still look at the Wakey game as the big let down where they would have got the points if they didn't clock off in the last 10. They always seem to run Wigan close especially at home so that should be a good game.

I thought Cas looked okay. They were the better team for good chunks of the match just couldn't get over the line. Two forward passes, Carney's brainfart, Lomax getting his hand to Shenton's inside pass when guys were queueing up score, Solomona dropping it with the line at his mercy. Really fine margins and on another day luck would have been on their side and they would have won. I don't think Cas fans should be getting down on themselves, they look a decent side, just didn't quite happen for them last night.

And one of those forward passes wasn't! Still don't think Cas were all that though. Much of their attack looked uncoordinated and clumsy, passes went behind players to no-one... Even though Leeds benefited from some dubious decisions in the first half (largely, though not entirely, squared up in what looked like an equalising process in the second half), I can't honestly say Cas did enough to win.

They didn't look super slick admittedly, but neither did Saints. Cas made loads more metres, more offloads, more breaks and had more of the ball. It just wasn't their night. Kinda reminded me of Hull over the last few seasons. Compete well in every area of the game, but can't find a way to score.

On the one hand I don't think Cas did enough and often looked in disarray with ball in hand close to the line, although they looked better organised in th second half.

On the other hand they were well and truly up against the ref. Some awful decisions, although the one he got right in binning Amor is of course derided by Sains fans lol

watching the catalan game, carney looks class! kicked one 40/20 already and a few metres short on another


warrington slowing the ptb at every opportunity, you can here thaler shouting held and move to their players yet still taking an age to clear

Carney has looked good for his first hit out, but Catalans aren't playing any better than just ok. Warrington have been very poor, there's no energy or enthusiasm in anything they have done and errors have killed them.

Well, it was ok to do it last weekend even when we were playing under the supposed SL interpretations, cant remember one single penalty for holding down and there was plenty of it.

Catalans obviously look a lot better with Carney and SD in the team but Warrington have been shocking, Wheeler in particular has been terrible.

Thaler is clearly Letting the game like flow and warrington are taking advantage of the ruck speed

You've been brainwashed by the Sky commentary team mate. One of the two 'controversial' forward pass calls was actually a mile forward, the other one was flat at best. A 50/50. Could have been given and would have been on another night, but certainly not a 'shocker'.
I still don't even have a clue what Amor was sinbinned for? Perhaps I'll have to watch it back.

He got binned for a Crusher Tackle. Tbh it looked worse especially in slow motion than it was. It was all a bit pointless anyway from Amor considering Cas were on their own 10 anyway.

IMO it wasn't a proper crusher in the true sense of the word, where you push the head down of a tackled player towards the ground and it jolts/traps the neck. Which are obviously very dangerous when a tackler gets it wrong and can lead to serious injury. Amor put his weight down on the attacking player but didn't seem to me to trap his head and neck in any way but I suppose the ref was closer. Maybe the ref thougt that it was borderline and there's no room in the game for them, so peanilsed.

Hull KR 22 Wigan 20 FT

Hull KR beat Wigan 22-20.

Wigan 20-6 up and lose 22-20.

*ss*