Why does that make him over-rated??? Surely it just makes him a poor defender

Don't think Wigan played tonight BB

He can defend it's just that he comes out the line to quick and either leaves him self stranded or his wing man

1. Shaun Briscoe
2. Ade Gardner
3. Tony Clubb
4. Kirk Yeamen
5. Lee Smith
6. Paul Cooke
7. Richie Myler < winner hands down
8. James Graham
9. Mick Higham
10. LMS
11. Jon Wilkin
12. Carl Ablett
13. Joe Westerman

Coach: Brian Noble.

So no Wigan players, plus the best prop in the country?

No Wigan players are rated in the first place (see signature).

And no way is LMS the best prop forward in the country.

Nonsense, I rate Joel Tomkins very highly. And his scruff rat of a brother.

I'm posting this because of earlier post's....

How the hell can Wellens be in your most over rated 13..
The guy has been a legend at full back for one of the most sucsessful teams ever in super league. He won man of steel. There is no club medal that man hasn't won.

There is seriously alot of people on here of whom don't know our game....... My advice stop talking and do all real RL fans a favour and do one

A slug could beat him in a 100m race and he makes far more mistakes then people give him a bad time about, he's never been the best FB in the league never mind world and one of the least deserving players of the MOS.

Ill have what ever your on please mate

Gaslight..... It's idiots like you I'm talkin about..... Ok wellens is flawed with his speed but all his other attributes such as ....... One on one tackles..... Posistional play on defense..... Posistional play on attack..... Ability to catch a high ball under immense pressure....

Seriosly Gaslight the list goes on.... Not once did I mention he was best in the world.... All I said he doesn't deserve to be in the most over rated......

Apart frommaybe 2 or 3 SL clubs, all the rest would love WWellens at there number1..... So as I said before..... Do one... You do t know the game dick wad

James Graham - Overated >

Try telling that to the props in SL that he dominates every week. Add Morley to that list after tonight and that was Graham playing with concussion.

No he isn't. He looks good at Leeds because Senior lays 25+ tries on a plate for him each season. Then imagine the likes of Folau, Boyd and the Morris twins running rampant down his wing at international level. He's the most overated player in super league.

You don't become RLIF rookie of the year if players tear rampant down your wing, which they didn't in the four nations.

Ben Harrison overrated - LMAO.

Easy...

1. Roberts
2. Gardner
3. Carmont
4. Sykes
5. Fox
6. Cooke
7. Brough
8. Fielden
9. Leuleui
10. Bailey
11. Wlikin
12. Ablett
13. O'Loughlin

1. McGoldrick
2. Gardner
3. King
4. Senior
5. Calderwood
6. Briers
7. Myler/Monaghan
8. Carvel
9. Clarke
10. Bailey
11. Anderson
12. Jones Buchanan
13. every other loose forward except for Sean O'Loughlin, who is brilliant and would be a sensation in aus (Nathan Brown), is one of the most skilfull loose forwards of his generation (Daniel Anderson), saves injured animals (RSPCA) rescues children from burning buildings (Wigan Fire brigade) and on whom



the last action hero was really based(Arnold Swazenneger)

Briers and Mongahan overrated, have a word with yourself.

Richie Myler

Yes?

You're only as good as your last game and last night they were pitiful. Thought your forwards were pretty good (hence they only scored one more try than you) despite what a lot of posters have said.

The big let down was from your half-backs and admittedly the saints luck, having sold their souls to the devil a long time ago.

1. Brent Webb
2. Ade Gardner
3. Matt King
4. Chris Bridge
5. Pat Richards
6. Lee Briers
7. Rob Burrow
8. Gareth Carvell
9. Micheal Monoghan
10. Stuart Fielden
11. Jon Wilkin
12. JJB
13. Sean O Loughlin

Quote ="Chief Scout"James Graham - Overated > Try telling that to the props in SL that he dominates every week. Add Morley to that list after tonight and that was Graham playing with concussion.'" considering he is so good i dont think these stats are that bad considering he plays a good 60 min game and lovegrove plays 50mins www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010

Quote ="Chief Scout"James Graham - Overated > Try telling that to the props in SL that he dominates every week. Add Morley to that list after tonight and that was Graham playing with concussion.'" considering he is so good i dont think these stats are that bad considering he plays a good 60 min game and lovegrove plays 50mins www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010

1. Jordan Tansey
2. Peter Fox
3. Michael Shenton
4. Lee Smith
5. David Hodgson
6. Richie Myler
7. Luke Robinson
8. Epalahame Lauaki
9. Shaun Lunt
10. Andy Coley
11. Dean Widders
12. Jon Wilkin
13. Joe Westerman

14. Scott Moore
15. Jamie Jones-Buchanan
16. Nick Fozzard
17. Vinnie Anderson

Now I don't necessarily think all these players are poor, far from it, just often hyped up to be more than they are.