Got to be Rob Burrow for picking on Hame Lauaki in the CC

absolute nonsense..total b*llo**s

Just watched that and couldn't make much out. I did like Boyd's gay little kick at the ruck when he was being wrestled by John Holdsworth.

Sean Long must be the winner? Last time he had a wash was when Wire won the league.

Paul Davidson. Played to London Broncos about 10 years ago.

He has got to be the worst forward along with Phil Adamson to ever have played for Saints,even worse than Ricky Bibey.

Beat me to it



If big Keef wasnt there to defend Lauaki I reckon Burrow would have leathered him

why?
maybe cos no one has said Bailey yet



has to be Les Boyd, closely followed by Tuuta, Paul Round and Tallis

No it isn't.

Warrington fan, are you?

Roundy was one hard b@st@rd.

Tallis wasn't dirty, just hard. Watch his fight with Terry O'Connor, was an absolute cracker.

With the videos around these days its impossible to build up a dirty play CV like the old timers had - anyone who tried would soon be out of the game. So in a blast from the past

Len Casey.

Specialised in cheap off the ball hits on the oppositions half backs because they were smaller. He filled his pants when he did it to Fred Ah Koui though and copped a hammering back.

Your other top thugs like Boyd, Mills, Reilly, David Watkinson, Eric Hughes, Mick George,etc took on anybody.

Casey was just a low piece of dirt.

He landed a few beauties thats for sure

So did Tez

What was it Terry said afterwards? "My wife hit's harder."

Paul Davidson.
Terry Newton.
Jamie Bloem.

And of the lot running round nowadays, I'd say Ben Westwood.

I feel insulted that TMFMISL has not been mentioned!

Kurt Sorensen.

Alan Rathbone wasn't shy when it came to a bit of bif.

Surprised no-one has mentioned Jason Hooper. An expert at shoulder charging kickers off the ball.

Quite ironic that he had to retire due to a shoulder injury.

Whilst I love watching Kevin Brown, I can never forget the night I sat next to the Wigan bench, and until he was used as an interchange he spent the whole time 'gobbing' onto the ground. As he always looked so young I felt like clipping him round the ear, glad I didn't.

Saints have always had more than their fair share...Nickle and Matautia are a couple that spring to mind.

Another was Chris Arkwright who seemed to have something against any Leeds half back and John Holmes in particular! Remember an "A" team final at Headingley in 1990/1991 ish where he managed to get a few Leeds players assisted from the field and then finally got sent off after a fair few late shots on Holmes!

Karl Fairbank and Chris Burton are another couple of forwards from the same time that deserve a mention!

Brendan Hill anyone?
Rathbone was a pure thug I agree.

The March brothers deserve a mention.

Type "March" in to the disciplinary section on the RFL website and you get a pretty long list.

kelvin skeritt what a head case he was when there was trouble you could count on him being involved i also though adam fogerty was a nut case as well dont think he knew how to tackle lower than the neck line