Call the game off by all means. I have no problem with that. What I do have a problem with is the failure to spot it before then and without the assistance of a member of the public. That is no way to run a competition what system is in place it would appear there is none.

It's not much of a way to run a professional sports club either.

Presumably the RFL trust their member clubs sufficiently to do their own eligibility checks before every fixture, irrespective of the competition.

Maybe relying on RLFans.com is their system?

All this talk of spreadsheets and live updates to ensure a player isn't illegally played.

A bit of communication to the players stating 'they' are playing illegally if they play for two teams and fine the player in question if they play would stop it instantly I bet!

Maybe its not fair to put the responsibility into the hands of the player as its not that hard is it really but I bet if a player was looking at a £2000 fine if he played illegally this would never happen again.........simples!

Players are entirely responsible for what they put into their bodies, so why not apply a similar position here. The rules on eligibility aren't exactly difficult to follow, even for big daft lads like RL players.

The Player is an idiot for playing for two clubs
The Club are idiots for allowing him to do so
The RFL are idiots for taking so long to realise and postponing a game at short notice and for costing their member clubs money

everyone involved comes out with little credit

and STILL after a WHOLE day the RFL shows it's total lack of teeth in making a DECISION YET AGAIN!!!
















stock is what this game is becoming!!!

Wheres the gonads like the Aussies have?

cheating set of s! hope you get whats coming to you!!!

Cheating my .Incompetence maybe,but cheating,no.Fax would be confident of beating Swinton and Batley without risking an ineligible,quite average player and all the subsequent recriminations of being found out.

Breaking the rules isnt cheating?
Why do fans of so many clubs think that is true

I reckon there is a distinction between breaking the rules with malice of forethought or inadvertently. Pretty clear which category this falls into.

Decision at 11am...

and
you
are
out of here!

Fax disqualified, Swinton to play Batley on 19th May.

[urlhttp://www.carnegiechallengecup.co.uk/article.php?id=17640[/url

One rule for Super League, one rule for CC!
Typical RFL bias against CC clubs!

And quite right too.

Erm, you do know that the rule stating a club could be expelled for fielding an ineligible player wasn't actually in place when Hull FC did it, don't you?

Typical fan of a Championship club...

And i bet they couldn't wait to use it!

& Calland has been suspended by the club while they carry out an investigation

You're wrong i'm afraid. Hull set down the marker for what NOT to do - backed by a new RFL directive.

100% justified.

You'd prefer fax to pay a 100K fine?

If we had gotten to the final I would have been quite happy to pay the same ammount as Hull did.

There,s clearly something wrong with the RL registration system for CC if this has happenend again!!

Its clear that the blame lies soley with Fax for picking the player. But how would this have been picked up if someone on this message board hadnt mentioned it?

If a kid cheats in an exam but the invigilator doesn't realise because he's reading a newspaper and has to be informed by another kid, the cheating kid is totally responsible for his actions and the invigilator is totally responsible for failing to do his monitoring job properly. Each have failed in their duty, each should mend their ways.

The failure of the monitoring system caused the last minute cancellation. Swinton should have been back in the cup the Monday after their tie with Fax.

Can't believe the RFL are getting away with this one. Are they seriously telling us their system is 'if someone dobs them in we'll act, otherwise we'll just sit on our hands'? It's going to take a cup-winner being retrospectively disqualified for them to make the piddling effort. to set up a spreadsheet to stop all this, isn't it... All so avoidable. Can't believe there's so few on here that can see it.