So you lambast a single Wakey fan for being typical, while stating he's being one eyed in his response?

Pot and kettle ...

If the disciplinary are being consistent it should be sending off sufficient and no fine.

Sinfield's transgression was much worse than Welham's. The RFL disciplinary process is more complex than the superficial spin put on it by fans and one head butt is not the same as another. It would be scandalous if Sinfield received the same punishment for his blatant, aggressive butt that Welham did for little more than rubbing heads with Dorn back in February.

Only just seen the incident. It looks like Sinfield took massive offence to Dorn asking the ref for a penalty when Sinfield was clearly all over him. Ironic really.

I can see little difference between the 2 except that Welham is on the floor. Definite use of his head into an opponents. I don't see how it would be scandalous at all. Welham was obviously annoyed for some reason and lost his cool a bit, stuck his head into Dorn's. Same as Sinfield.
And Welham wasn't red carded for it. If anything it'd be a scandal if Sinfield got more than Welham.

Given that he's had an unblemished record for nearly 20 years, I think the mass hysteria on here is laughable. Where was this outrage when chris welham had no red card or ban for his headbutt earlier in the season?

Oh yeah I forgot, he doesn't play for leeds.

Clean record, early guilty plea, will probably end up with 2 games and people on here will be screaming bloody murder and calling for the death penalty.

My god your a slow, desperate and sad creature you are - noticed your moderating didn't last long



So again Thaler is not a Wakey fan ffs and even if he were why would that benefit Leeds. As Cas fans love to chant "we all hate Leeds"

Don't get a chip on your shoulder - most Wakey fans myself included see it as a storm in a tea cup pumped for all it's worth by Gronk and a few of the other Cas loons.

Sir Kev I don't so , 4 game ban.

That makes no sense. Want another go?

2 game ban after egp,nowt more,get it done and move on

Absolute diabolical a can't speyk

Worst headbutt I've ever seen. It was a terrible act of aggression on a rugby pitch.

I mean f you're going to get yourself sent off you should at least draw blood. That was pathetic dorn looked like he didn't feel a thing. Crap headbutt terrible

Let us put this into perspective .

If you were in a pub and it kicked off and somebody landed a nod on you like that one ..... What would be the result ?

I for one would be more offended than injured by it , and the person that nodded my way would be swiftly sat on their buttocks on the floor .
If I landed one like that I would be embarrassed .


Headbutt ..Schmeadbutt .

Can tell the lad is from the West of the Pennines . If he was from the East they would still be scraping bits of nose off the grass this time next week . Especially when you take into consideration the forehead of Sir Kev .

6 match ban for such a pathetic attempt if it is decided that it was actually a 'headbutt'

Needs to take a few lessons off Big Jim Mills!

I think I'd give it 3 to 4 matches.

He got a red, but it was only 8 minutes. So assuming he goes guilty and given his record it will be the lower end of the punishments.

It was a headbutt, but for me it was a halfway house between a full on headbutt and Sinfield trying to put heads together.

Doubt it would be 1, that's the kind of thing you get for a lazy swinging arm that goes to high.

What's your betting he gets grade A and zero games for good behaviour



IMO it's never a grade A, nor a grade E. Its a definite C, but this is the RFL so the "obvious" choice goes out of the window. Wonder if they have a club vote like every other decision they have to make.

What is clear is that the independent tribunal can't please everyone as the range of opinion on here sways from 0 games to 5.

So let's just start the whinging and biased allegations now....

*delete as appropriate*
Can't believe he got 0 games. Bluddy disgrace. RFL in Leeds pocket as usual. He would have been banned for life if he played for [i<insert team you support>[/i

Can't believe he got X games. RFL are clearly out to get Leeds. It was Shaun Wanes fault for mouthing off about it mid-week. He would have been let off if he played for [i<insert team you hate>.[/i

You can make a case for any amount.

Can't believe he only got 2 games so that he'll be back for the challenge cup (Wire fans)

Can't believe he got 3 games, RFL obviously wanting Wire in the challenge cup again like every year, how many people at the rfl with front row Take That tickets now. (Leeds, Widnes and Wigan fans).

About right for me. Reckon he'll get 2 games with good disciplinary record [size=50(even if he is a niggly sod)[/size.

I thought with Grade C and above, you don't have the option of an EGP?

Wrong, A-C can submit EGP.

As long as Sir Kev isn't playing on Friday night against the greatest team ever to play out of Barton Graveyard Stadium, I don't care how many more games he misses after that..

To be fair, he is the Gary Lineker of RL, fantastic talent and gentleman who annoys only a few

2 game suspension following early guilty plea confirmed.