there we would agree. both sides have had great and terrible decisions for and against them

"got controversy written all the way through it"

Stevo speak for badly officiated ! its been shocking even by this seasons poor standards

Don't be stupid. It's a sending off every day.

Fakir should've been off also.

"Wasn't much in it".... Typical thicko Leeds fan.

The ref has been awful. Terrible performance.

Bernard has a point methinks.

Me thinks Wigan fans are a weeny bit scared of the mighty Rhinos.

Love how the Wigan fans are still insisting all contact with the head is the same. Mcguire was silly, but not in any way, shape or form similar or on a level with Mcilorum's. Fakir's aswell. Both were mistimed swings at falling players, Mcilorums was a late, high, swing at a static player, if you cant tell the difference between them then you are beyond help and we would be best to leave you festering in your bitterness.

wigan away is one tough prospect especially after a tough game in france and wigan having a rest. thats the advantage you get when you turn up week in week out. brian macdermott take note

The most badly refereed playoff game this season. Maguire should have been given 10 mins at the very least. Hall should possible have got the same for his cowardly push at Dureau's back. The less said about Peacock's offside arm grab the better. And will someone please remind Sinfield that being an NFL blocker every time someone puts a bomb up is not aloud?

Leeds fan.

As i said, if you cant tell the difference, i cant help you. Its you that suffers in you're bitterness though so, you're welcome to it.

only notice one teams fouls then? bitter, very bitter

Please don't tell me I've just read a Wigan fan saying the McGuire incident was the same as mcalorrum. Don't be daft, McGuire will get a one game ban, it was a swinging arm not late and on a player tgat was falling, the Fakir on burrows was just as bad if not worse. Anyway what a great game jury what playoffs are about, I'm sick of moaning RL supporters you do the game a dis service.

I don't mind the refs errors being pointed out, but what a surprise a Wigan fan ONLY mentions the ones that go against Catalan. Just makes you sound bitter and biased. Infact you are bitter and biased.

If anyone should have got 10 in that, it should have been Dureau for going down easier than Beeston's finest, Even Ferriol looked disgusted with him

Great record, don't you remember the Rugby Gods?

And McIllorum, whilst your campaign of anti-Wigan rumbles on you should really look at his record, maybe it's best not to let the facts get in the way of a good witch hunt?

rugby gods? then when most of wigan were wishing he would never play again? disgusting. i would never wish injury never mind a career ending one on anyone

I didn't say it was the same. McGuire's and Fakir's challenges (high tackle and raised elbow) were all red card offences if you ask me. It's the inconsistency by the SAME REFEREES that is wrong.

The Fakir incident was the worst of the match, he should've been off. McGuire should be looking at a 1 match ban, he had more than enough time to pull out of that one with a falling player, otherwise not much in it. I want him to be banned for the sake of consistency, but I'm a bit upset he shouldn't be coming to Wigan. Would love for us to knock Leeds out at full strength, but they shouldn't be after that shot.

So how is that inconsistency. Thats not inconsistency, its just referees thinking one offence is a red card, two different ones arent and you disagreeing.

If you want a laugh head over to the Wigan forum, I've never read such a load if paranoid nonsense.

It's not a matter of opinion. There is a rule book y'know.

Methinks that might be the last we see of Ben Thaler in these playoffs. Leeds were the better side on the night though so deserved to progress.
The odds of us seeing another Leeds Saints GF grow shorter every week, how monotonous.

Clearly it is a matter of opinion or we wouldnt have referees but a computer up in the stands. The rules are there to be interpreted, you interpret them different from the referee in these two incidents.

And the Saints fans are a teeny weeny bit afraid of whomever gets to the final with Saints (if they get there).