Good call. He’s been immense this year.

Saints have the slowest back line in Superleague...........but they have scored the most trys in superleague.

James Roby has been far and away our best player this year so he would be my nomination from Saints.

Meli was easily the best winger on the pitch against Wigan last weekend.

Be nice if he won it and actually deserved it

Is it just an allergy to Old Trafford he's got then FTV?

He's certainly allergic to kicks - he even messed one up early doors at Wigan (which they should have scored from) to prove that, even in his best games, he's a disaster waiting to happen.

Not hard when your opposite number is Feka.

He's the best winger in sl and it's not even close but then again you did say leon 'thug' pryce should be so dont know why i'm supprised

6&7 are the same position this day and age doesn't make a diffrence

Mind you if you want to take that route it shows how good pryce is when people who dont play his position get in before him

FAIL

And scores a try at Dave Whelan stadium.

Anyone know where you can bet online for MOS?


I think the odds have it right. Pat Richards and Kyle Eastmond the stand outs for me. Pat started at 50/1 before coming in to 7/1.



Biased probably but Pat is top try scorer, top goal scorer and top points scorer by a clear 90 points so it has to be him - at the moment.

I assume anyone picking anyone other than Paddy Richards is on some sort of wind up / joke ?

Why? Just because he is top scorer doesnt make him MOS. If it hadnt been for a VERY dodgy refs call David Hodgson would be top try scorer.

He tore through wigans defensive line with ease

Thicker than a tub of whale spunk.



When did Myler and Eastmond play at 6 for England?

Eastmond was 6 v aussies sam was 7

England: S Briscoe (Hull KR); Fox (Hull KR), Bridge (Warrington), Shenton (Castleford), Hall (Leeds); Tomkins (Wigan), Eastmond (St Helens); Morley (Warrington), Sinfield (Leeds), Graham (St Helens), Peacock (Leeds, capt), Ellis (Wests Tigers), Burgess (Bradford). Interchange: Crabtree (Huddersfield), Wilkin (St Helens), Westwood (Warrington), Roby (St Helens).

FAIL.

no order

puletua
cunningham
bridge
richards
senior
j tomkins
fitzgibbon

Tony Smith plays his half backs left and right, as opposed to scrum 1/2 at 1st reciever and your 5/8 2nd reciever, so he's not completely off target.

The game at dw did eastmond not come on at 6 replacing mcguire?

Thought so

Did Tony Smith tell you that Eastmond played in a role that's he never even played at club level? You must be well in with him.

Look, we can go round in circles. I'm happy to have Leon Pryce playing at 6 for Saints. I don't think he will win MOS, nor should he. I took exception to KW saying that Pryce was past it, when he clearly isn't. I've also got a problem with him saying that 4 players should get picked at stand off (which I regard as a fairly specialist position) and then naming 2 scrum halfs. It's like me saying that Sean O'Loughlin is the 3rd best 13 for England and then naming Burgess as one of the two better than him.

If it helps the arguement any I always say that England should play Leon Pryce on the bench as he is capable of playing in pretty much every position outside the front row.

When has points scoring ever come into a MOS vote?

I wonder how forwards have ever got it previously, considering they don't score points by the sack loads.

It is pish easy for a goal kicker to be top points scorer, especially a winger. Pish easy is not a criteria considered in MOS.

Pat Richards may well be a shoe in for the dream team, even possibly player of the year, but he is as far removed as a contender for MOS as I am from getting to sleep with Cheryl Cole.