I’m not saying that at all. I’m saying he also made mistakes in Wigan v Hull game and also the Wigan v Saints game.
Yes all refs make mistakes, I just think he’s made a few too many recently to be a shoe in for GF, that is all.

So why on the Wigan page have you literally just wrote:

“Seeing as the club twitter announced he had failed an HIA and wouldn't be back, it would be interesting to see a report of what happened

If they have put him back on with any issues then they need to be made an example of by the RFL/SL.”

None of which were "howlers". Just the same type of error made by every referee in every game as I illustrated using last night's game. The reason you think they're an issue is because they were against Saints or for Wigan. When they're for Saints they aren't an issue and certainly not one big enough to preclude the ref from getting the final.

No one is suggesting he is a shoe in. NK suggested he'd be his choice to which you replied "surely this is a wind up" (sic).

Bloody hell you’re like a dog with a bone with me haha.

NK said he should “rightfully” get the GF which is what I disagreed with, due to his recent catalogue of mistakes. Nothing to do with Saints or Wigan. If you want to assume otherwise that’s fine but I don’t have the energy or inclination to go round in circles arguing about it.

Because it will, because you haven't clarified what happened instead you made a joke about it and hid the original post. Had you done that, we wouldn't be having this conversation.

I doubt you have put him back on but if you have you should be rightly punished. Agree?

Which is his opinion. Why would that be a "wind up"? It seems like as reasonable a choice as any other

You know why I'm like a dog with a bone with you

Indulge me one more time. If it's nothing to do with Wigan or Saints then list me the "howlers" he made that went against Wigan in the recent derby.*


*Or, perish the thought, you could concede that I'm right.

Eamonn, calm down. Your rant in the programme a couple of weeks after the 2019 cup final made you look sad and bitter, but to bring it up again 15 months after the event says much more about you. Do like any other club chairman would do and take it on the chin, congratulate the winners and move on.

In the last few games:

He should’ve sent Greenwood off
He should’ve sent McIlorum off.
He missed a forward pass for Harry Smith’s try.
He wrongly penalised Connor when French knocked on.

In my OPINION, those are all howlers. They also have nothing to do with my feelings for Saints or Wigan.

I am more than happy to agree to disagree mate.

Yes I agree. But if you’re sure they haven’t put him on with issues I don’t understand why you’re suggesting there is a chance they have, that’s all.

Neither of those were mistakes never mind "Howlers".

He did send Greenwood off unless you mean you think it should have been a straight red in which case it's a judgement call and not a howler.
I'll agree on Mcllorum but the same goes for the video ref. The other 2 were correct calls.

And against Wigan please?

I have already listed the two main ones v Wigan.

No, not the ones that went against Saints. The "howlers" that went against Wigan.

In which game?

Turning into an interrogation now this it’s a bit boring mate haha. I don’t actually know what you’re trying to prove.

I think Kendall has made a lot of errors recently and shouldn’t ref the GF. I genuinely don’t know what you’re trying to achieve here by cross questioning that. You’re trying your best to find some bias that is swaying my opinion, just so you can score a point.

We can agree to disagree; let it go.

I don't think you could get your head around the fact that there was a communication problem. We don't even know if the chap on the twitter account got information from the SKY team, Jenna Brooks herself in fact didn't say he had failed the HIA test she said LMS will take no part in the game which confused things.

LMS came off the field at the 29 min mark and the tweet was announced on the 38 min mark, I should imagine it would take longer than 9 mins to confirm a test and get it out to the media in that time scale, the player has to undergo a rest period protocol before taking the SAT test. Like I said before the result was probably confirmed during the interval period and not in a premature tweet by a non medic.

In my opinion thats not particular hard to understand. However if there is any suspicion circumstances the RFL would have certification proof and we would have heard something by now.

Because you aren't answering! The Greenwood one was a Wigan offence. I'm asking you to give me the howlers he made that were Saints offences. It's really not that complicated....

Well that’s the first time you’ve made your question clear....

Off the top of my head I genuinely can’t remember any in that game. I’m happy to look at any examples you have though and answer them honestly.

I’ve clearly stated Moore made errors last night that benefited Saints so bias doesn’t come into it.

What exactly are you trying or prove? That all refs make mistakes? I agree. All clubs benefit from them at different times? I agree. That no team is given special treatment? I agree. Anything else?

Because there is bias. There is always bias. From every fan of every club. Just because you refuse to acknowledge it doesn't make it any less true. And if course I'm trying to prove a point. Just as you are with all your posts and everyone else does with theirs!

I do agree it's getting boring though so we'll leave it that Kendall shouldn't get the final because he makes mistakes that don't favour Saints. You good with that?

Nope, all good with that mate. It's exactly what I said in the very first post.

No I’m not because you’re taking what I’ve said and completely twisting it, which seems to be your regular tactic.

I am going to say exactly what I think so you don’t have to to twist it, misinterpret it or infer some other hidden meaning.

I do not think Kendall should be some sort of automatic choice for the Grand Final. The reason for this opinion is that I believe he has made several mistakes recently, all in high profile games. I would also like to acknowledge that all referees make mistakes, however I believe he has made too many recently to warrant being the front runner for the GF.

That’s the last you’re getting off me on the topic. So you can dangle any bait you want, I’m not biting. The above paragraph leaves no room for your little games.

Have a great day.

He was so bad he's been punished with reffing the Grand Final.

Deserves it after an imperious display in that last Wigan vs Saints game. Come up with the same again and everyone is happy.

Giving him the GF was the only thing that could be done to stop Saints winning at a canter. At least with him in charge it gives Wigan half a chance

With Moore getting the CC Final, Thaler Hicks and Child seemingly out of favour with Ganson, Kendall seems the obvious choice.

The McManus hissy fit if it was awarded to Hicks would have been spectacular.