Any other Wigan player you'd like to vote for? I personally think Darrell Goulding has had an excellent season!

Monaghan, Fitzgibbon and I think Morley is also a worthy candidate too.

Pat Richards is the only one that should even be in consideration. If anybody else wins it will be a disgrace.

Pat Richards is . A typical, average, run of the mill NRL outside back. Nothing special at all. Like Barrett he is a myth. He is solid enough, he can catch, he can kick goals. But does he do enough to win MOS? Does he go the extra mile the previous winners have done? I'm not so sure.

And yet he'd walk into any team in the league, as would "average" O'Loughlin.

I do,don't get me wrong Monaghan is a fine player but for me Roby is the best hooker in the league.

Disagree with you there Saddened,Richards is the best winger in the league IMO.

Funny, we had 2 hookers playing yesterday both of whom out played Monaghan.

I think he's overrated, but I know the Sky team love him so you're probably right about him being in the dream team.

He is overated. He was anonymous yesterday

Not better than famous Amos, the sure fire 100% confirmed man-of-steel-in-waiting?







Wigan fans are just getting giddy because of their temporary stay at the top of the league. They'll be nominating Feka next when he manages 15 minutes in a game.

So in your opinion there are 2 STAND OFFS who are currently better than Pryce in the SL. I asked you which stand offs were better than Pryce. You named 2 scrum halfs.

Goulding has not had enough impact on the whole team. Monaghan, Morley and King could also win it.

If Leeds finish the season strongly don't bet against either Peacock or McGuire being in the running either.

Monaghan had an absolute stinker yesterday; first time in a long while whereas buderus had a great game.
This year from what ive seen though Monas has been the best, of course imo

Fair enough - I've not seen him week in week out so suppose I can't comment.

When interviewd after the England/France game Peacock said he felt O'Loughlin was the best player in the League.
The players now decide MOS and if Lockers keeps his form when he returns from injury then he has to be there or there abouts for the award.

Look just give it to Craig fitzgibbon.

Now.

Then we can draw a line under the thread and stop arguing.

He is the best player in the ESL by a country mile

LOL your online persona is occasionally funny but in this thread you just look flippin retarded

Players quite often take the pish with the media. I am certain this was one of those cases. That or Peacock had taken a nasty bang on the head in the match.

Most of the time he's played he's been the best Hooker on the pitch though.


He was outplayed yesterday, but there are times when every player will be outplayed, even Greg Inglis or Billy Slater.

So you havn't been watching.

Of course he/she/it hasn't.

Definitely. If that's his opinion of Richards, I can't imagine what his thoughts must be of Meli and Gardner.

Meli is not a bad winger he just makes errors at crucial times.

And runs with all the pace and venom of an asthmatic snail.

Ian Kirke