I think Derwents idea is awesome and Id make the trip up for such a game.

Honestly TrinityIHC, I'm not comparing the two directly. Only that the comment was made that rugby should support the South Pacific as it was rugby's community. Cumbria is just that.

We are not talking vast sums here, but anything raise for the volunteer services would surely be welcomed and a nice show of unity for the people who have been hit by the awful events of the last few days.

Come on RFL, I know you guys read this forum - what can you do?

Great idea. Cumbria playing against attractive opposition would be a great shout for the game.

Has anyone contacted the rfl with this idea? spread the word and i'm sure that the rfl would listen and support the idea.

It would have my support even if the amount raised is small it would just show our support.It would also help out the non profit agencies who do so much to help.

Speaking as someone who all my life has been involved in responding to disasters around the world from the Bangladesh floods in 1969 to flood relief in Mozambique (due to being involved with Helicopter operations) the reason you hear an apeal for help from poor counties is because they have nothing to help themselves with. This country we pay our taxes national & locall & they are required by law to have contingencys in place to pay for & deal with emergencys they dont always get it right but they are co ordinated & train for it, the forces Armed & civil are equiped to respond. even the NHS will have had lists of blood donors ready if they needed to call on them non of this gets much publicity as it just seems to happen. It is one benefit of living in a stable country in a stable part of the world. The people in Cumbria will have seen this first hand & will know the work of the savation army & WRVS ect.

Applaud everyone for pushing this and really hope the RFL do pay attention and work overtime to get a fundraiser on.

But if any of you really want to give something to help those affected: [urlhttp://www.cumbriafoundation.org/[/url

Ah, yes. Who could forget how the RL community rushed to organise a benefit game for the people of Hull when we were flooded a couple of years back (also resulting in a death)?

err no.

to compare the situation of that in Cumbria to that in the Pacific region is laughable

These people (should) have insurance, they have the NHS - i'm sure they can cope with a wet carpet, broken TV and a bit of a longer commute to work.

No, no and no.

Its about time people in this country stopped this infatuation with begging. We pay plenty of taxes to cope with mishaps like this.

Hey, any banks flooded? That should get the government to throw in a couple of BILLION

What a great idea. A fine and noble idea indeed.

What a great idea. A fine and noble idea indeed.

Really taking the moral high ground you, aren't ya! Trying to say these people are less deserving than those people - why should I care... blaa blaa...

Rugby League fans stick together mate.

Yeah, and two wrongs make a right. Grow up.

It wasn't necessary then, and it isn't necessary now. There are far more deserving causes.

Its all well and good but if it were to happen it would only (realisticly) raise peanuts

Hence the reason, if you're gonna claim to care - which clearly some don't - then just make a small donation and give over with all the making out like you care.

Agree with Cheshire Tiger that some on ere maybe need to think of others, but can't agree with him that making a donation is different from a fundraiser. Nobody's forced to donate money or turn up at a fundraiser.

What a sorry lot. I only hope you're never in the same boat - no pun intended (honest!)

So does putting 20p in an RNLI collection box, but it all adds up

What I mean is people cant be bothered to turn up for Challenge cup games so they are hardly going to turn up in their droves for a charity game

Great idea but I honestly just don't think it would be well attended!

No reason at all why it wouldn't be well-attended. Call it RL Aid and let's do our bit.

Did they have a relief fund for the Hull population in 2007 ???

Yeh thought not!!!

Maybe your idea of well-attended is different to mine. Do you really think they could get a good 10,000 on?

Depends on the situation, but why not? We're not talking about some Super League box ticking exercise, expansion argument or any other of the tripe that's on here, but instead doing our bit to help out our own and actually show some of this 'RL community' spirit that people are so often keen to point out.