Quite simple really who is the dirtiest player you have ever seen.

For me it's Terry Newton after what he did to Lee Gilmour and Sean Long in the Wigan v Saints game in 2005.

Sonny Nickle wasn't exactly whiter than white.

If it was Top Trumps, Newton would be close to the top in both the dirty and stupid categories.

Who can out do Les Boyd- 12 month ban followed 2 games later by 18 months

Quins picked Danny Williams up from Aus during an 18 match ban

Les Boyd, although the warrington fans have him on some sort of pedastal as "hard but fair" when in reality he was just an out and out thug

A thug with immense talent though, he could do the good stuff as well as the rough stuff.

Terry Newton and Les Boyd are good shouts .

But I'll go for Jim Mills, ex Widnes and Wales.

No need for racist slurs on rlfans.

The dirtiest player now is obviously Sean O'Loughlin. He hasn't yet managed a tackle below the neckline.

How the HELL is that a racist comment?

You really are an idiot!!

If you meant this you are a complete idiot. Not only that but extremely ignorant.

I suspect he will return soon to pass it of as a tounge in cheek remark.....

Which is exactly the way I read it...

OT - Tim Street.

Sonny Nickle

As did I.

Re Sonny Nickle - in his second stint at saints he went very well with no disciplinary problems before the infamous Robbie Mears incident, which really was a baddun.

Does anyone remeber Brendon Tuuta? He was forever up to no good.

Paul Gallen ... (Awaiting McKenzie

).

Also +1 for Ryan McGoldrick. That guy is always giving someone a cheapshot.

'Smokin' Joe Grima.

When he was at Keighley he either played an absolute blinder or got himself sent off.

Joe Grima
Paul Cullen
Eddie Syzmyla
Timmy Street
Les Boyd
Terrence Newton
Richie Eyres

Les Boyd. Dirty 'orrible little ocker scrote. Gouging is about as low as you can go.

Beautiful video of him getting some comeuppance on YouTube, something akin to "Cop That Les" might be worth a search. The 1988 New Year's Day battle and his little scuffle with Hanley in Milwaukee 1989 also on there.

Les Boyd, without a doubt. Followed by Mark Geyer.

To say Terry Newton was habitually dirty is wrong. Boyd set out to incapacitate players in every match he played - Newton's defining moment was the Gilmour/Long games, which whilst terrible, was not typical.

Newton was more of a houser than an out and out dirty player; his problem was he wasn't smart enough to disguise it, like a lot of other players.

You know for years ive listened to warrington fans gush about the time les boyd said he was going to smack hanley all over the pitch and then how during the game Boyd leathered Hanley. So imagine my surprise when I found the video on youtube and saw nothing of the sort!!!!

Richard Chapman, a real pantomime villain.

Newton for 2005.

Nigh on 2 pages and i'm in shock!